Then Derek Foster took the stand, and this was the moment everyone had been waiting for, though I had been dreading it, because whatever else Derek was, he was someone's son, and watching a young man unravel in a courtroom is not entertainment, even when he has done what he did. His lawyer had clearly coached him, and at first he stuck to the story: he had been walking past, he had not damaged the car, Caleb Hart had staged it, the Moss family had misunderstood what they saw, the video did not show what people thought it showed. Rachel Torres let him tell it, all of it, without interrupting, and then she began, gently, to take it apart, piece by piece, the way you take apart an engine that has been put together wrong, not with force but with patience and the right tools. She played a short clip of Ethan's footage and asked Derek to explain the key in his hand. He said it was his own car key. She asked him why his own car key would leave a scratch down the side of a Lamborghini. He said he did not know the scratch was there. She played the Escalade footage and asked him to explain the mirror. He said the mirror was already broken. She asked him how he knew the mirror was already broken if he had only been walking past. He hesitated, and the hesitation stretched, and you could feel the whole courtroom holding its breath. She asked him about the tyre, and he said he did not know anything about the tyre. She asked him about his mother's car down the street, and he said his mother had been visiting a friend. She asked him which friend, and he could not name one. She asked him about the text messages Detective Laura Kim had recovered, messages between Derek and his mother from that evening, and she read one aloud, a message in which Lorraine had written that the car needed to be dealt with, and Derek had replied that he would handle it. Derek said the messages were taken out of context. Rachel Torres asked him what context would make "handle it" mean "walk past it," and Derek had no answer. His voice, which had started out steady, grew thinner and thinner, and by the end he was contradicting himself within the same answer, saying he had not been there and then describing where he had stood, saying he had not touched the car and then explaining why he had touched it. His lawyer tried to stop the bleeding on redirect, but there was nothing to redirect to, because the testimony had collapsed under its own weight, and when Derek stepped down, he did not look at his mother, and Lorraine did not look at him, and that silence between them said more than any verdict could.
The closing arguments took a full day. Rachel Torres spoke first, and she did not raise her voice, and she did not need to. She walked the jury through the case as if she were walking them through a house they had already visited: the car, the cameras, the minutes, the money, the messages, the second night tow attempt that Deputy Tom Alvarez had stopped for lack of a lawful order, the recall that had already spoken for the neighbourhood. She said this was not a case about a car, though a car had been damaged, and it was not a case about a neighbourhood dispute, though a neighbourhood had been divided. It was a case about people in positions of trust using those positions to take money and to punish anyone who asked questions, and about a young man who had been sent to do the punishing and had been caught on camera doing it. She asked the jury to hold each defendant accountable for what that defendant had done, no more and no less. The defence lawyers spoke after her, and they did their jobs, arguing reasonable doubt, arguing mistakes and misunderstandings, arguing that Lorraine had been a volunteer doing her best, that Carl had trusted the wrong paperwork, that Vince had been a contractor who billed as he was told, that Derek had been a son who made a terrible mistake under pressure. Some of it was true, in the narrow sense, and some of it was not, and the jury listened with the grave attention of people who understood that what they decided would change lives.
Judge Margaret O'Neil gave her instructions to the jury with the same calm clarity she had shown throughout, explaining the charges, the burden of proof, and the difference between what a person did and what a person intended, and then the jury filed out, and the waiting began. Waiting for a jury is its own kind of time, slow and elastic, and June and I spent it in the corridor with Sarah and Daniel, who had driven in from Austin, and with Robert and Angela and Ethan Moss, drinking bad courthouse coffee and talking about anything except the verdict, which is to say we talked about the weather and about Ethan's channel and about the garden June wanted to replant in the autumn, and every time the corridor door opened, we all looked up. It took the jury less time than David Chen had predicted, which David said was usually a good sign for the prosecution, though he cautioned me not to read too much into it, because juries are human and humans surprise you.