"I resented the will," he said, and the admission seemed to cost him more than all the rest put together. "I resented it from the day it was read. I sat in Corbett's office and I heard him read those words — to my daughter Adriana — and I thought, why her? Why not Damian? Why not the son who carries the name? I never said it aloud. I told myself it was unworthy of me. But it sat there, year after year, and after your mother died, and the house got quieter, and the days got longer, it grew. I told myself I was thinking of the family. I was thinking of myself. I was thinking of an old man sitting alone in an empty house, watching everything he built slip away, and wanting to hold on to one thing — one beautiful, shining thing — and call it the family's, and give it to the son who still bore my name."
Adriana felt her throat close. She had wanted anger from him, or excuses, or a fight — anything she could push against. What she was hearing instead was something far harder to answer: a lonely old man admitting, quietly, at a table in a restaurant, that he had been afraid and proud and resentful, and that he had let all of it curdle into a theft.
"And Gianna's family," Damian said, his voice flat now, the shaking gone, replaced by something colder. "You said something once — about Gianna's family. About impressing them."
Augustus nodded, slowly, his eyes on the tablecloth. "Gianna's family is well-off. Respected. I wanted — I wanted them to see that the Montagues were still a family of standing. That we could give a bride jewels like those. I wanted to bind Gianna to us. To make the engagement — to make it grand. To make it something her family would admire." He looked up at Gianna, and his face crumpled slightly. "I am sorry, Gianna. I used you. I used the jewels to impress your family, and I used your engagement to justify what I did. That was wrong. You did nothing wrong."
Gianna opened her eyes. She was looking at Augustus with an expression Adriana had never seen on her face before — not anger, not tears, but a kind of clear, cold dignity, as if she had stepped back from the whole scene and was seeing it for the first time from a distance.
"I believed you," she said to Damian, quietly. Her voice was steady, though her hands in her lap were trembling slightly. "When you gave me the ring, you said it was a family gift. From your mother. I believed that. I was proud. I wore it everywhere. I showed it to my mother, to my sister. I told them it was your mother's ring." She paused, and her eyes moved to the photograph on the table, to Antonia laughing in the sun. "It was your mother's ring. But it was not yours to give."
Damian turned toward her, his face stricken. "Gianna, I didn't know. I swear to you, I didn't know. Papa told me — he told me Mama would have wanted you to have them. I believed him. I thought — I thought it was a gift from the family, from Mama herself. If I had known, I would never —"
"I know," Gianna said. She reached out then, and took his hand, and held it for a moment, her fingers cool against his. "I know you didn't know. I can see that. But Damian — the ring he proposed with was stolen from your sister's safe by your own father."
The words landed heavily, and Damian flinched, but he did not look away from her. Adriana watched her brother's face as the three realisations settled over him, one after another, each one worse than the last. First, the ring — the ring he had knelt with, the ring he had slid onto Gianna's finger with such pride, the ring he had chosen his words over so carefully — had been taken from his sister's safe on a Sunday morning while she was away visiting her daughter. Second, his father had lied to him about their mother, had put words in a dead woman's mouth, had told him she would have wanted Gianna to have the jewels when her will said the exact opposite, in writing, in a document his father had executed himself. And third — the worst of it, Adriana could see it in the way his shoulders dropped — his father had used him. Had handed him the stolen jewels and let him carry them to Gianna, let him be the one to give them, so that if anything ever came out, it would be Damian's hands that had held them, Damian's proposal, Damian's gift. He had been the instrument, not the heir.
"Papa used me," Damian said, very quietly, as if he were only now hearing the thought in his own head. "He used me to take what was never his to give. He let me propose with a stolen ring. He let me stand in front of Gianna's family and give her stolen jewels."
"Damian," Augustus said, reaching across the table toward his son, but Damian pulled his hand back, and Augustus's hand hung in the air for a moment before he let it fall.
"No," Damian said. "Don't. Not now."
The restaurant had gone almost entirely silent around them now. Adriana could feel the weight of the room's attention, the held breath of thirty tables, the waiters standing still by the service doors, the maître d' hovering at a careful distance, close enough to step in if he were needed, far enough away to pretend he was not listening. A woman at a table by the window had turned her chair slightly away, as if to give them privacy, and a man at the bar was studying his drink with great concentration. No one was staring openly. Everyone was looking away, and that was worse, in a way — the whole room politely pretending not to hear what they could all plainly hear.