What the General Carried on Pine Hollow Road

Chapter 23

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Angela Brooks kept an office on the second floor of a brick building in downtown Savannah, above a bookstore, with a waiting room that smelled faintly of coffee and old paper and a receptionist who took my name without making me repeat it twice. Brooks herself was in her early fifties, sharp-eyed, direct, and economical with her words in the way that good trial lawyers often are. She did not offer me sympathy first. She offered me a notebook, a pen, and a question. She asked me to tell her what had happened, from the beginning, without skipping the parts that embarrassed me or the parts I was unsure about, and she listened without interrupting, making notes in a hand that was fast and legible at the same time. When I finished, she asked me a second question, which was whether I had preserved everything, and I laid out on her desk, in order, the tow ticket photograph, the two receipts from Doyle's lot, my contemporaneous notes, the certified telematics printout and disc, Helen Marsh's footage and statement, and my own written account. She examined each item slowly, turning pages, checking dates, and then she looked up at me and said, "General, you have done half my job for me, and you have done it in the right order. Most clients come to me with a grievance. You have come to me with a record."

Brooks explained, in plain language, what we would do next, and she did not promise me an outcome she could not guarantee. She told me that we would file formal complaints through every proper channel at once, rather than waiting for one agency to decide whether it was interested, because a single complaint in a small county could be filed and forgotten, while parallel complaints create a record that is harder to lose. She told me that she would write to the sheriff's office demanding preservation of all records relating to my stop, my booking, my property, and the tow, including radio traffic, body camera footage if any existed, and the booking log itself. She told me that we would seek the return of the $900 and reimbursement of the $925 I had paid to recover the Highlander, and that we would do so in writing, with copies kept, so that no one could later claim the request had never been made. She told me, too, that she would advise me not to discuss the case publicly or on social media while complaints were pending, not because I had anything to hide, but because a clean record is a stronger record. I retained her that afternoon, I signed the engagement letter, and I paid the retainer from the account I kept for professional expenses, feeling the familiar, grounding sensation of having placed a complex operation in the hands of a competent officer, even if that officer wore a suit instead of a uniform.

The complaints went out over the following week, each one typed, each one signed, each one sent by certified mail and by email, each one logged in a file Brooks kept and in a file I kept separately. We filed a complaint with the Cedar Bluff County Sheriff's Office itself, addressed to the internal affairs function, setting out the false speed claim, the arrest on alleged resisting and DUI with a breath test result of 0.00 that had never been logged, the denial of a phone call, the missing $900, and the incomplete tow paperwork. We filed a complaint with the county commission, asking for an audit of towing practices and of the financial relationship between the sheriff's office and Doyle Towing. We filed a complaint with the Georgia Peace Officer Standards and Training Council, which certifies law enforcement officers in the state. We filed a report with the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, asking for a criminal investigation into the taking of property and the falsification of records. And we filed a complaint with the Federal Bureau of Investigation's civil rights division, setting out the same facts and asking for a federal review, because the pattern I was beginning to suspect, even then, was larger than one stop on one road. Brooks told me to expect silence first, then questions, then, if we were fortunate, action, and she told me that silence in the first weeks did not mean the complaints had failed.

It was during that period of waiting, when the complaints had been filed and the formal machinery had begun to turn at its own slow pace, that the case took the turn I had hoped for but had not dared to count on. The turn did not come from a press release or a dramatic confrontation. It came quietly, in the way that important things in small counties often do, through a person who had been watching from inside and who had decided that watching was no longer enough. I received a message through Angela Brooks, not directly, because the person in question did not want her name on a phone record or an email that could be traced back to her desk. The message said only that someone who worked in dispatch at the sheriff's office wished to speak to my attorney, in confidence, about booking records. Brooks called me immediately, and we met in her office that same evening, with the blinds drawn and the door closed, to discuss how to handle an approach that could help the case enormously and could also cost the person making it her livelihood if it was handled carelessly.

News in the same category

What the General Carried on Pine Hollow Road

45 Part