The mock cross-examination was harder than the direct preparation, and Angela did not pretend otherwise. She stood up, changed her posture, and became, for an hour at a time, each of the defence lawyers in turn, asking the questions they would ask, in the tone they would use. She asked me whether I was certain about my speed, whether I might have glanced down and missed a moment of acceleration, whether the Highlander, being a larger SUV, might have felt slower than it was actually travelling, whether I had been distracted by looking for the venue in Savannah where I was due to speak, whether I had been tired after a long drive, whether I had any reason to dislike law enforcement, whether my rank and my training made me, in her words as the defence lawyer, "someone who expects to be obeyed, even by a deputy on a country road." She asked me whether I had really asked for a telephone call three times or whether I might be remembering one request as three, whether I had really counted nine hundred dollars or whether I might have spent some of it on the journey and forgotten, whether I had really been told I was under arrest for resisting when I had simply asked questions, whether my memory of the night might have been shaped by the investigators who had interviewed me afterwards. Each question landed like a small, deliberate push, and I learned, over those sessions, to pause before answering, to breathe, to answer only the question asked, and to say "I do not recall" when I genuinely did not recall rather than filling a gap with a guess that could later be called a contradiction. Angela taught me to look at the jury when I answered, not at the lawyer, because the jury was the audience that mattered, and to keep my voice steady even when a question was insulting, because steadiness was itself a kind of testimony. She also taught me what not to do, not to argue, not to explain beyond the answer, not to volunteer the wider scheme or the other motorists unless asked, because the prosecution would build that part of the case through documents and other witnesses, and my job was to be unimpeachable about my own night. By the end of the third session I was exhausted in a way that reminded me of the final days of a field exercise, the kind of tiredness that comes from sustained concentration rather than physical effort, and Angela looked at me across the table and said, "You are ready, Naomi. Not because you will have an answer for everything, but because you know what you know, and you know how to say that you do not know the rest. That is what a jury trusts." I believed her, or at least I wanted to believe her, and I went home and slept deeply for the first time in weeks, though I dreamed of Pine Hollow Road and woke with my heart beating fast, as if the dream had been another cross-examination I had not yet passed.
What the General Carried on Pine Hollow Road
Chapter 32
Theme:
Font Size:
24px