The third attack was the most personal to the people who had risked their jobs to tell the truth, because it was aimed at Dana Whitfield's duplicate booking log. Sykes's lawyer argued that the log was hearsay, that it was a private notebook kept by a dispatcher without authorisation, that it had no official status, and that admitting it would allow the prosecution to present a second, unofficial version of events created by a witness who now had her own reasons to cooperate with the government. Doyle's lawyer joined the argument, contending that the log's entries about cash and invoices were conclusions, not observations, and that the defence could not cross-examine a notebook. Angela had warned me this would be the closest call, and I felt my hands go cold as the prosecutor stood to respond, because Dana was not in the room that day and her absence made the notebook seem, for a moment, like an orphaned piece of paper. The prosecutor argued that the log was admissible as a record of regularly conducted activity, kept by Whitfield in the course of her duties as dispatcher, made at or near the time of the events it recorded, and corroborated in every material respect by independent evidence, including the missing breath-test entry in the official log, the missing cash receipt, and the tow records that matched the duplicate invoices. He called Whitfield's supervisor, who testified, reluctantly but truthfully, that dispatchers in Cedar Bluff County had long kept handwritten backup logs because the computer system crashed frequently, and that Whitfield's log followed the same format as others he had seen. He called the federal investigator who had compared the duplicate log, entry by entry, with the official log, and who testified that where the official log was silent, the duplicate log spoke, and where the official log recorded an event, the duplicate log matched it, except for the omissions that formed the heart of the case. The judge took a long pause before ruling, reading through her notes, and then she denied the motion to suppress the duplicate log, with a careful explanation that its admissibility would be revisited entry by entry at trial, that the defence could object to individual entries, and that Whitfield herself would have to testify and face cross-examination before the jury could give the log weight. It was a partial victory, hedged with conditions, but it was a victory, and as we left the courtroom that afternoon in the rain, Angela said quietly, "They threw everything they had at the evidence before trial, Naomi, and the evidence is still standing. That matters. Now we have to make sure you are ready to stand with it."
Preparation with Angela Brooks began the following week in her office, a room with tall bookshelves and a window that looked out over a parking lot, where the light fell in long rectangles across a conference table covered in binders, each one labelled with a witness name or an exhibit number. Angela was not the kind of lawyer who offered empty reassurance, and I was grateful for that, because empty reassurance would have left me unprepared for the questions that were actually coming. She started by walking me through my own statement, page by page, and asking me to say aloud, in my own words, what had happened on Pine Hollow Road, from the moment I saw the patrol car in my mirror to the moment I was released at eleven oh four in the morning. She stopped me whenever I summarised, whenever I said "and then they did this" without the detail, and she made me go back and supply the detail, the exact words Granger used when he told me I had been doing fifty-two in a thirty-five, the exact tone of his voice, the way the light from his torch had moved across the dashboard of my Highlander, the way my hands had stayed at ten and two on the steering wheel because my training had taught me that stillness was safety. She asked me about the breath test, and I told her again that it had read zero point zero zero, that Granger had looked at the device and then had not written the result anywhere I could see, and that I had asked him, politely, whether the result would be recorded, and he had told me not to worry about the paperwork. She asked me about the telephone call I had been denied, and I told her that I had asked for it three times, once at the roadside, once at the booking desk, and once in the cell corridor, and that each time I had been told to wait, and that the wait had lasted the whole night. She asked me about my property, and I told her that my medication had been placed in my property bag at booking, that I had watched Sykes seal the bag, and that when the bag was returned to me the following morning the medication was there but the nine hundred dollars in cash that had been in my wallet was not, and that no receipt had ever listed it. She asked me about the tow, and I told her that Doyle's truck had arrived quickly, that my Highlander had been winched onto the flatbed while I stood handcuffed beside Granger's patrol car, and that I had been charged six hundred forty dollars for the impound and two hundred eighty-five dollars for storage, nine hundred twenty-five dollars in total, before I could recover my own vehicle. Angela wrote notes as I spoke, not interrupting except to clarify a time or a phrase, and when I finished she said, "Good. Now say it again, shorter, because cross-examination will try to make you hurry, and hurrying is where witnesses lose precision."