The trial itself opened on a Monday morning in the same federal courtroom where the motions had been heard, but the room felt different with a jury in the box, twelve men and women and two alternates, ordinary people from Cedar Bluff County and the surrounding area, who had been questioned for two days about whether they could be fair to a sheriff they might have voted for and to a Black woman general from out of town who was accusing him. I sat in the gallery behind Angela during jury selection, watching faces, trying not to read too much into any one expression, and I noticed how carefully the judge explained the presumption of innocence, how she told the jurors that an indictment was not evidence, that the prosecution bore the burden of proof, and that the defendants did not have to prove anything at all. When the jury was finally seated, I felt a strange mixture of exposure and relief, because now the case would no longer be argued in motions and press statements but in front of people who would hear the evidence itself. Angela had told me I would testify on the second day, after the prosecution's opening, so on the first morning I sat with my hands in my lap and listened as the prosecutor stood, buttoned his jacket, and walked to the centre of the courtroom to address the jury. He was a tall man with a calm, unhurried manner, and he did not raise his voice, which made what he said feel heavier, not lighter. He told the jury that this was not a case about a single traffic stop gone wrong, though it began with one, on Pine Hollow Road, where a woman travelling alone to speak at a veterans ceremony in Savannah was stopped for doing fifty-two miles an hour in a thirty-five-mile-an-hour zone when in fact she had been doing thirty-four. He told them that the stop was the door, and that behind the door was a system, a system in which traffic stops became revenue, in which cash disappeared from property bags, in which tow charges were billed twice, in which booking logs were rewritten to hide breath tests and denied telephone calls, and in which, over four years, thirty-one motorists had lost a total of three hundred forty-two thousand seven hundred dollars. He told them they would hear from the woman herself, Brigadier General Naomi Bennett, and from Helen Marsh, whose dashcam had recorded the truth of that evening, and from Dana Whitfield, whose duplicate log had preserved what the official log had erased, and from a telematics expert who would explain, in plain language, what the Highlander itself had recorded. He told them the defence would argue that these were mistakes, that records were messy, that memories were imperfect, and he asked the jury to weigh those arguments against documents that did not forget, against video that did not blink, and against data that did not have a motive to lie. He finished by saying that the government did not ask the jury to trust any one person alone, but to trust the pattern that emerged when all the evidence was laid side by side, and then he sat down, and the courtroom was quiet for a moment before the judge called a short recess, and I realised my hands were shaking, not from fear, exactly, but from the sudden reality that my night on Pine Hollow Road was now a story being told to strangers who would decide what it meant.
When I took the witness stand the following morning, I was acutely aware of every detail of the room in a way I had not been as a spectator. The chair was hard and slightly too high, the microphone in front of me caught the sound of my breathing until I learned to speak past it, and the jury box was close enough that I could see individual faces, a young woman with a notebook open, an older man with his arms crossed, a middle-aged woman who met my eyes and then looked down at her hands. Angela led me through my direct testimony with the same steady pace she had used in her office, and I told the story from the beginning, slowly, in first person, in the past tense of memory, because that was how it had happened and how I remembered it. I told them I had been travelling alone to Savannah to speak at a veterans ceremony, that I had been driving my dark-grey 2021 Toyota Highlander, that I knew the road and I knew the limit, thirty-five miles an hour, and that I had been holding my speed at thirty-four, checking my speedometer out of habit, because a logistics officer learns to check instruments without thinking. I described the patrol car in my mirror, the lights coming on, the way I had pulled over promptly onto the shoulder of Pine Hollow Road, the way I had kept my hands visible and my voice calm, and the way Granger had approached and told me I had been doing fifty-two in a thirty-five. I told the jury that I had been surprised, that I had said, respectfully, that I believed I had been doing thirty-four, and that Granger's expression had hardened at that, as if a question were itself a form of resistance. I described the breath test, the device, the reading of zero point zero zero, and the fact that Granger had not recorded it, and I described the moment he told me I was under arrest for resisting and for driving under the influence, words that had sounded absurd in my ears even as the handcuffs closed around my wrists. I described the tow, Doyle's truck, the winch, my Highlander rising onto the flatbed, and the helplessness of watching my own vehicle taken away while I stood beside a patrol car on a country road at dusk. I described the jail, the booking desk, Sykes sealing my property bag with my medication inside it, the wallet that had held nine hundred dollars in cash, the requests for a telephone call that were met with "wait" and then with silence, the long night in a cell where the light never fully went out and the sounds of the jail, doors clanging, voices in the corridor, water running somewhere, kept me awake until morning. I described my release at eleven oh four, with no charges, no apology, no explanation, and the return of my property bag without the nine hundred dollars, and the bill I later paid to recover my Highlander, six hundred forty dollars for the impound and two hundred eighty-five dollars for storage. I did not embellish, I did not raise my voice, and when Angela asked me how that night had affected me, I said simply that it had taught me that a record could be rewritten while you were still living inside it, and that I had come to court because I did not want that to happen to anyone else. The prosecutor thanked me, and the judge said the witness was tendered for cross-examination, and I took a breath and prepared myself for the part Angela had warned me would be the hardest.