What the General Carried on Pine Hollow Road

Chapter 36

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The telematics expert followed her, and his testimony gave the jury the technical spine that Angela had promised it would. He was a methodical man who spoke slowly, as if he were explaining a piece of equipment to new recruits, and he described how the Highlander stored speed, braking, and location data, how he had retrieved it under a documented chain of custody, and how the data showed my SUV travelling at thirty-four miles an hour, steady and unvarying, on a road posted at thirty-five, in the minutes before Granger's lights came on. He displayed a graph on the courtroom monitor, a flat line at thirty-four with no spike toward fifty-two, and he explained that the margin of error for the system was less than two miles an hour, so that even at its outer limit the data could not support the claim in Granger's report. The prosecutor then used the expert's foundation to introduce the wider financial records, and the jury heard, through an auditor who followed him, how Doyle Towing had billed the county and motorists twice for the same tows, duplicate invoices totalling sixty-one thousand dollars, how cash taken at booking had gone unlogged across cases totalling forty-four thousand eight hundred dollars, and how, over four years, thirty-one motorists had together lost three hundred forty-two thousand seven hundred dollars through inflated impounds, duplicate storage charges, and cash that was never receipted. The defence cross-examination of the expert was thorough but, to my ears, increasingly strained, because each attack on calibration or on satellite signal ended with the same answer, that no plausible error turned thirty-four into fifty-two, and each attack on the auditor ended with another document, another invoice, another signature, laid on the projector for the jury to see.

The defence case, when it finally came, faltered in a way that was visible even to someone who was not a lawyer. Callahan did not testify, and Granger did not testify, and Sykes did not testify, each exercising a right that the judge explained carefully to the jury was not to be held against them, but their silence left the defence lawyers to argue through other witnesses that the discrepancies were mistakes, that the logs were messy, that the tow charges were clerical errors, and that my speed might have been misjudged in the dark. The witnesses they called, a former deputy who said record-keeping in the county had always been sloppy, a tow-yard employee who said duplicate billing happened by accident when paperwork was copied, could not explain why the sloppiness always ran in one direction, why the errors always favoured the sheriff's office and Doyle Towing, or why the breath test that would have cleared me was the one entry that had vanished entirely. Their testimony, under the prosecutor's cross-examination, grew vague, with answers that began "I suppose" and "It could have been" and "I do not recall," and by the final afternoon of defence evidence the courtroom had the tired, restless feeling of a proceeding running out of ground to cover. Closing arguments followed, the prosecutor reminding the jury of the flat line at thirty-four, of Helen's video, of Dana's handwriting, and of the pattern that tied one night on Pine Hollow Road to thirty-one motorists over four years, and the defence reminding them, in turn, of the presumption of innocence and of the burden the government bore, and asking them not to convict on documents alone. The judge then charged the jury, slowly and carefully, on the elements of each count, on reasonable doubt, on the weight to give expert testimony, and on the duty to consider each defendant separately, and when she finished she looked at the twelve men and women in the box and said that the case was now theirs. The foreperson stood, the jurors filed out in single file through the side door, the bailiff closed it softly behind them, and the courtroom, which had been full of voices for days, fell into a waiting silence while I sat beside Angela, my hands folded, listening to the faint hum of the lights and the sound of my own breathing, knowing that everything that could be said had now been said, and that the next words in this case would not come from any lawyer or witness at all.

The courtroom did not feel like a courtroom at all on the morning the jury came back. It felt like a room that had been holding its breath for too long, and the air had gone thin inside it. I sat at the counsel table beside Angela Brooks, my hands folded on top of a legal pad I had not written a single word on since the judge sent the jury out, and I tried to keep my breathing steady in the way I had been trained to do when a briefing was running long and the room was full of people waiting for someone else to decide what happened next. The wood of the bench behind me creaked every time someone shifted. The fluorescent lights hummed low over the ceiling. Outside the tall windows, the late light fell across Pine Hollow Road in the distance, pale and ordinary, and I could hear, faintly, a truck changing gear on the highway beyond the courthouse square. Angela did not look at me. She looked at the empty jury box, her pen capped and resting between her fingers, and I knew from the stillness in her shoulders that she was doing the same thing I was doing, which was refusing to guess.

News in the same category

What the General Carried on Pine Hollow Road

45 Part