What the Pentagon Exposed on Hawthorne Ridge Road

Chapter 21

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The fourteen days passed. Okafor called me again. He said, "They sent us a partial production. Arrest logs for the last six months only. No fine sheets. No impound records. No bond records. No dispatch audio. The letter accompanying it says the remaining records are still being located."

I asked him what he thought. He said, "I think someone is deciding what we are allowed to see."

The second request went out, firmer this time, with a deadline and a warning that a subpoena would follow. Voss responded with a letter of her own, polite and brief, saying that the clerk's office was a small operation, that the records were voluminous, that she was doing her best, and that she would need additional time. Okafor read me the letter over the phone, and I could hear the patience in his voice thinning, the way a careful man's patience thins when he is being managed by someone who thinks he will not notice.

"She's stonewalling," I said.

"She's stonewalling," he agreed. "And stonewalling is its own kind of evidence, Captain. When someone with nothing to hide is asked for records, they hand them over. When someone delays, and delays again, and sends you half of what you asked for with an apology, it tells me there is something in the other half that they do not want me to see."

He told me he was preparing a subpoena, and that it would be served the following week, and that he wanted me to know before it happened, because once a subpoena lands on a county clerk's desk, the whole county knows about it by lunchtime.

I said, "Let them know."

That night I added a new page to the timeline, headed "Federal inquiry — records requests," and I wrote down every date, every letter, every phone call. Okafor's request. Voss's acknowledgment. The partial production. The second request. Voss's letter. The subpoena, pending. I wrote it all down in ink, in my small slanted handwriting, and I put the page in the folder in the safe, next to the fine sheets.

The county was delaying. But delay is not the same as disappearance, and I had learned in Briar County that the people who delay are the people who are afraid of what the records will show.

---

Earl Whitfield did not wait for the subpoena. He went on the record first.

He is sixty-three, a county commissioner in Briar County, and he has held his seat for longer than I have been in the Navy, and he speaks the way men who have held a seat for a long time speak, as if the county itself were agreeing with him. He gave an interview to a local radio station in Briar County, and then he gave a statement to the Savannah Gazette, and Priya called me the morning it ran to tell me what he had said, before I read it myself.

He said that Sheriff Roy Callahan was a good man and a fine lawman, that he had served Briar County for decades, that he had kept the roads safe, and that the people of Briar County trusted him. He said that the complaints against him were coming from outsiders, from people who did not live in Briar County and did not understand how things worked there. He said that the federal inquiry was an overreach, that Washington had no business telling Briar County how to run its sheriff's office. And then, in the part of the statement that Priya read to me twice, slowly, so I would hear every word, he said that Captain Simone Hayes should drop the matter, that she should go back to Washington and let Briar County handle its own affairs, and that continuing to press the issue would only cause trouble for everyone involved.

"Trouble for everyone involved," I repeated, after she finished reading.

"That's what he said," Priya said.

I sat at my desk at the Pentagon and looked out the window at the Potomac, and I thought about what a public warning from a county commissioner means when it is printed in a newspaper. It means he is not afraid of being quoted. It means he believes the county is behind him. It means he is telling the rest of the county, in plain language, that the sheriff is protected, and that anyone who challenges him will be treated as an outsider who does not belong.

I called James Whitaker. He listened, and then he said, "Save the statement. Print it. Put it in the folder. A public warning from an elected official to a federal complainant is evidence, Simone. It goes in the record."

I called Okafor. He had already seen it. He said, "Captain, I want you to know that Commissioner Whitfield's statement does not change anything about the inquiry. If anything, it tells me we are looking in the right place."

I did not call my aunt Gloria. I did not want her to worry. But that evening, when I was sitting at the kitchen table with the folder open in front of me, Marcus came in and put his hand on my shoulder and said, "You know what your aunt would say."

I said, "I know. Don't let it go."

News in the same category

What the Pentagon Exposed on Hawthorne Ridge Road

45 Part