What the Pentagon Exposed on Hawthorne Ridge Road

Chapter 37

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Commissioner Earl Whitfield was the last witness, and he was sixty-three years old, and he walked to the stand with the slow, deliberate step of a man who had spent his life being the most important person in every room he entered, and he sat down, and he folded his hands, and he looked at the jury as if he were addressing a county commission meeting. Whitaker began with his position, his years in office, his authority over the sheriff's budget, his authority over the clerk's office, his authority, in short, over the county in which the scheme had operated for three years.

"Commissioner Whitfield," Whitaker said, "did you know about the altered fines?"

"No, sir," Whitfield said. "I did not."

"Did you know about the cash collections?"

"No, sir."

"Did you know that Sheriff Callahan's office was stopping motorists at night, on Hawthorne Ridge Road, and on other roads in this county, and citing them for violations that did not exist?"

"No, sir. I did not."

Whitaker put the campaign finance records on the monitor, and he walked Whitfield through them, contribution by contribution, date by date, and the contributions from Rucker, and the contributions from a company Rucker owned, and the contributions from a second company that shared Rucker's address, and the totals, which rose in the months when the ledger's totals rose, and fell in the months when they fell. Whitfield said the contributions were lawful, and that he had reported them, and that he did not know where the money had come from. Whitaker put the county commission minutes on the monitor, and he showed the jury the meetings where Whitfield had voted to increase the sheriff's budget, and to approve the clerk's office expenditures, and to dismiss, without investigation, three separate complaints from motorists who had written to the commission about stops in Briar County, complaints that had named Callahan, and Boone, and Voss, and Rucker, by name.

"Commissioner Whitfield," Whitaker said, "you received three written complaints, from three different motorists, in three different years, each naming Sheriff Callahan, Deputy Boone, Clerk Voss, and Bondsman Rucker, each describing a stop, a search, and a fine that changed. What did you do with those complaints?"

"I referred them to the sheriff's office for review," Whitfield said.

"You referred complaints about the sheriff to the sheriff," Whitaker said.

"That is the procedure, sir."

"And the sheriff reviewed them, and found no wrongdoing, and you accepted his finding."

"Yes, sir."

"And you took campaign contributions from the bondsman named in those complaints, in the weeks after you dismissed them."

Whitfield's hands tightened on the edge of the witness box, and for the first time, the calm, commission-meeting voice faltered. "I did not know," he said. "I did not know where the money came from."

"Commissioner," Whitaker said, and his voice was very quiet now, "you knew. You knew because the complaints told you. You knew because the ledger, which was kept in the clerk's office, which you oversaw, told you. You knew because Sheriff Callahan told you, in the meeting the FBI recorded, when he said, 'Earl, we take care of each other in this county,' and you said, 'We always have.' The courtroom has heard that recording, Commissioner. The jury has heard it. You were not a bystander to this scheme. You were its protector."

Whitfield did not answer at first, and then he said, "I was protecting the county."

"No, sir," Whitaker said. "You were protecting the men who were stealing from it."

The closing arguments took a full day. The prosecution spoke first, and the prosecutor, a woman named Assistant United States Attorney Grace Liu, stood before the jury and told the story again, from the beginning, without embellishment, letting the evidence do the work it had already done. She told them about the stop, and the search, and the recording, and the fine, and the ledger, and the bank records, and the testimony of Tran and Ellison, and the testimony of Boone, and the admissions of Voss and Rucker, and the protection of Whitfield, and she added the numbers, one last time, twenty-two motorists, three years, two hundred and ninety-one thousand eight hundred dollars, and she said, "Ladies and gentlemen, this case is not about a broken taillight. There was no broken taillight. This case is about power, used against people who had no power, on dark roads, at night, in a county where the sheriff, the deputy, the clerk, the bondsman, and the commissioner believed no one would ever ask. Captain Hayes asked. Staff Sergeant Tran asked. Mr. Ellison asked. And now you are asked, to say what the law says, which is that what they did was a crime."

Hale spoke for the defense, and he spoke well, and he asked the jury to consider that Boone was a man trying to save himself, that Voss was a woman who had made mistakes in her paperwork, that Rucker was a businessman who had collected what he was told to collect, that Callahan was a sheriff who had served his county for thirty years, and that the government's case was built on the testimony of people who had a reason to blame someone else. He said the word "misunderstanding" again, and the word "mistake" again, and he asked the jury to find reasonable doubt, and he sat down, and the courtroom was quiet, and Judge Caldwell instructed the jury, and the jury left to deliberate.

News in the same category

What the Pentagon Exposed on Hawthorne Ridge Road

45 Part