What the Pentagon Exposed on Hawthorne Ridge Road

Chapter 33

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

When my turn came, Whitaker called me to the stand, and I walked to the witness box in my service dress blues, and I raised my right hand, and I swore to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, and I meant it in a way that went beyond the oath. I had spent twenty years as a judge advocate, advising commanders, prosecuting cases, defending sailors, standing in courtrooms where the law was the only thing between a person and the power of the state. I had never been on the other side of that line before. I had never been the person the state had come for, on a dark road, with no witness but a phone in my hand.

Whitaker began with the basics, the way he always did, building the foundation before he built the house. My name. My rank. My assignment at the Pentagon. My years of service. The route I had been driving that night, and why. The time, 8:47 p.m. I told the jury about the headlights in my mirror, about the patrol car pulling in behind me, about the blue lights flashing, about the way my hands had stayed on the wheel, ten and two, the way my father had taught me when I was sixteen, the way I had taught every young sailor I had ever mentored. I told them about Boone's flashlight in my window, about Callahan standing behind him with his arms crossed, about the question of the taillight, and the answer I had given, that the car had been inspected eleven days earlier, and that I would be happy to step out and look at the light with him.

"Captain Hayes," Whitaker said, "did you consent to a search of your vehicle?"

"No, sir," I said. "I did not. I said so clearly, twice. I said, 'I do not consent to a search of my vehicle.'"

"And what happened then?"

"Deputy Boone told me to open the trunk. Sheriff Callahan said, 'Do what he says, ma'am, and this goes easier.' I opened the trunk because I was alone on a dark road with two armed men, and I was afraid of what would happen if I refused. But I did not consent. I want the record to be clear about that. Fear is not consent."

Whitaker played the recording, and the jury heard it the way the judge had heard it, my voice steady, Boone's voice unhurried, Callahan's voice low and certain, and I watched the jurors' faces as they listened. One woman, in the front row, a schoolteacher by her questionnaire, closed her eyes for a moment when Boone said, "Ma'am, out here we don't need all that." A man in the second row, a retired truck driver, shook his head slowly, once, twice, the way a man shakes his head when he hears something he recognizes and wishes he did not.

Whitaker asked me about the fine, and I told the jury about the citation Boone had handed me, four hundred and eighty dollars, and about the phone call the next morning, when I had called the clerk's office to ask about payment, and Marlene Voss had told me the fine was one thousand nine hundred and fifty dollars, and that it had to be paid in cash, and that a bondsman named Dale Rucker would meet me to collect it. I told them about the ledger, not as a lawyer, but as a witness, the way I had seen it when Okafor showed it to me, the columns of names and dates and amounts, my name among them, the figures written in Voss's neat hand, the alterations visible where the ink changed, where a number had been written over another number, where a four had become a nine.

Hale's cross-examination was careful, and I respected the care, even as I answered it. He asked me if I was certain about the time, and I said I was, because my phone had logged the call to Marcus at 8:51 p.m., four minutes after the stop began. He asked me if I might have misunderstood Boone's request as an order, and I said, "Sir, I am a judge advocate. I know the difference between a request and an order. Deputy Boone did not make a request." He asked me if I had any reason to dislike Sheriff Callahan before that night, and I said, "I had never met Sheriff Callahan before that night. I had never been to Briar County before that night. I had no reason to dislike him. I have a reason now, and it is the evidence."

News in the same category

What the Pentagon Exposed on Hawthorne Ridge Road

45 Part