He asked me about the law, and this was the part of my testimony I had prepared for most carefully, because this was the part where I could speak not only as a victim but as a lawyer, and I wanted the jury to hear the difference. "Captain Hayes," Hale said, "you are familiar with the Fourth Amendment, are you not?" "I am, sir," I said. "Then you know that a traffic stop requires only reasonable suspicion, not probable cause." "I do," I said. "And you know that an officer may ask a motorist to step out of the vehicle during a lawful stop." "I do," I said. "And you know that an officer may conduct a search incident to arrest." "I do," I said. "Then is it not possible, Captain, that Deputy Boone believed he was acting lawfully?" "It is possible that he believed it, sir," I said. "It is not possible that he was acting lawfully. A belief does not create reasonable suspicion where none existed. A belief does not create consent where consent was expressly refused. A belief does not turn a four-hundred-and-eighty-dollar fine into a one-thousand-nine-hundred-and-fifty-dollar fine. The law is not what an officer believes on the side of a road at night. The law is what the Constitution says, and what the statutes say, and what the record shows. And the record shows that Sheriff Callahan and Deputy Boone stopped me without cause, searched my car without consent, and demanded money I did not owe, and that is not a misunderstanding. That is a violation of the Fourth Amendment, and a violation of 18 U.S.C. Section 242, deprivation of rights under color of law."
The courtroom was quiet when I finished, and Judge Caldwell thanked me, and I stepped down from the witness box, and Marcus stood in the aisle as I walked back to my seat, and he did not say anything, and he did not need to.
Staff Sergeant Alicia Tran took the stand the next morning, and she was twenty-nine years old, and she wore her Army uniform, and she sat very straight, and she told the jury about her stop, which had happened fourteen months earlier, on a different road in the same county, at 9:20 p.m. on a Friday night. She had been driving home from Fort Benning, where she was stationed, and Boone had stopped her for a broken taillight, and her taillight had not been broken either, and she had shown the jury the same inspection record, the same dash camera still, the same pattern, laid over mine like a transparency. She had been asked to open her trunk. She had refused, and Boone had opened it anyway. She had been given a citation for six hundred and twenty dollars, and when she called the clerk's office, Voss had told her the fine was two thousand one hundred dollars, and that it had to be paid in cash to Dale Rucker. She had paid it, because she was a staff sergeant, and she was afraid of what a warrant would do to her security clearance, and she had kept the receipt, and she had kept the citation, and she had kept the note she had written to herself that night, in the parking lot of a gas station, with shaking hands, because she had known, even then, that something was wrong.
Hale tried to shake her on cross-examination, and he asked her if she was certain about the amount, and she said, "Sir, I have the receipt in my hand. The receipt says two thousand one hundred dollars. The citation says six hundred and twenty dollars. I am certain." He asked her if she had reported the stop at the time, and she said, "I reported it to my first sergeant, sir, the next morning. My first sergeant told me to pay the fine and move on, because a soldier does not make trouble in a county she does not live in. I paid the fine and I moved on, until Captain Hayes called me, and I understood that I was not alone, and that I had not imagined it."
Robert Ellison took the stand after her, and he was sixty-one years old, a truck driver with thirty years on the road, and he spoke slowly, in the way men who have spent their lives watching the highway speak, and he told the jury about his stop, which had happened two years earlier, on a Tuesday afternoon, when he had been driving a delivery through Briar County and Boone had pulled him over for a cracked windshield that was not cracked. He had been ordered out of his truck, and his cab had been searched, and his logbook had been taken, and he had been given a citation for nine hundred dollars, and Voss had told him the fine was three thousand four hundred dollars, and Rucker had met him at a truck stop off the interstate and taken the cash in an envelope, and counted it in front of him, slowly, the way a man counts money he believes he is entitled to.
"Mr. Ellison," Whitaker said, "how many times were you stopped in Briar County?"
"Three times, sir," Ellison said. "Three times in two years. Same deputy. Same story. Same fine that grew between the road and the courthouse. The third time, I asked Deputy Boone why my fine kept changing, and he said, 'Mr. Ellison, out here, the price is the price.'"
"And what did you do?"
"I paid it, sir. I paid it three times. Because I had a truck to drive and a family to feed, and I could not afford to sit in a county jail while a sheriff decided what my freedom was worth. But I kept every receipt. I kept every citation. I kept every envelope with Dale Rucker's name on it. I kept them in a box in my truck, because I knew, one day, somebody would ask."