The first repetition was the towing company. Again and again, the name was the same: Pruitt's Towing, run by Marty Pruitt, who was fifty-three years old and who, according to the county's own contracting records, had held the county towing work for years. That alone would not have meant anything. Counties have preferred tow operators, and a single company handling most tows is not unusual. What mattered was what happened when David compared the invoices Pruitt's had submitted to the county with the invoices the motorists themselves had been given, and with the amounts the motorists had actually paid at the lot. In a number of cases, the same tow appeared twice, billed once to the motorist at the lot and once again to the county, for the same vehicle, on the same date, with the same impound number. The amounts were not always identical to the dollar, which made the duplication harder to spot at a glance, but the vehicle, the date, and the impound reference matched, and that matching was the tell.
David showed me the duplicate invoices one evening, laying them out in pairs on his desk, and I felt a cold, focused anger that was different from the fear I had felt in the cell. Fear had been about what might happen to me. This anger was about what had already happened to other people, people I did not know, who had paid and gone home and probably told themselves, as I had first told myself, that it was not worth fighting a county over a tow bill. When David added up the duplicate Pruitt invoices he could document from the records we had, the total was $49,000. He was careful to say that this was the documented total from the records in hand, not an estimate and not a guess, and that there might be more that the incomplete records did not yet show. I wrote the figure down, $49,000 in duplicate Pruitt invoices, and I stared at it for a long time, because it turned a single tow, my own tow of $590 impound plus $240 storage, into one small part of a much larger accounting.
The second repetition was cash. In case after case, the booking inventory either omitted cash entirely or recorded a smaller amount than the motorist said they had been carrying, and there was no receipt, no correction, and no later return recorded. My own $850, carried in my wallet for my grandmother's groceries and bills, had been omitted from the booking inventory altogether, and when I first told David about it, I had worried that I would sound as if I were inventing a detail to make my case sound worse. Seeing the same omission in other people's files, in different handwriting and on different dates, changed that worry into something else. It was not that my case was unusual. It was that my case fit a pattern, and the pattern was what made the omission credible, not less so. When David totalled the unlogged cash seizures he could document across the cases in the spreadsheet, the figure was $36,200. Again, he stressed that this was documented, not estimated, and again I wrote it down exactly as he gave it to me.
By the time David had worked through the records we had, the spreadsheet contained twenty-two motorists over two years, and the total amount involved across those cases was $296,800. I want to be precise about what that total meant, because precision was the discipline David kept insisting on, and because I did not want to claim more than the records showed. The $296,800 was the total across those twenty-two motorists over two years, including the $49,000 in duplicate Pruitt invoices and the $36,200 in unlogged cash seizures, with the remainder made up of tow, storage, and related charges that the motorists had paid and that, in the context of stops that did not hold up, formed part of the same pattern. It was not a round number invented for effect. It was an addition of documented lines, and David could show his working for it, line by line, if anyone asked. I asked him to show me his working, and he did, and I checked a sample of the lines myself, because I did not want to repeat a total I had not understood.
We sent the timeline, the dashcam copy, the telematics summary, and a summary of the pattern to the prosecutor's office through David, with a formal request that the obstruction citation against me be reviewed in light of the new evidence. David told me not to expect a quick answer, and he was right, because weeks passed in which I heard nothing except acknowledgements of receipt. I went back to work, I visited my grandmother in Tallahassee when I could, and I tried to live a normal life around a case that was not normal. My grandmother, Edith Whitfield, who was seventy-nine years old and recovering from her fall, asked me once, in her direct way, whether all this paper was helping or only making me relive the night, and I told her honestly that it was doing both, and that I thought it was still worth doing. She nodded, as if she had expected that answer, and she told me to keep my notes in order, which was her way of telling me to keep going.