What the Sheriff Took on Old Mill Road

Chapter 36

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Delaney's testimony turned to the jail, and it was, in some ways, the most uncomfortable part of the trial for me to hear. He was 49, a jailer deputy, and he spoke about booking as a process of intake, property, and waiting, about nights when several people arrived at once, about nurses who were called when they were available, and about logs that were completed after the fact from notes and memory. He said the omission of the $850 from the inventory had been an error, not a taking, and that the delay in my medication had been a matter of procedure and timing, not a deliberate denial. He said the call delay had reflected jail operations, not punishment. The prosecution, on cross-examination, returned him repeatedly to the duplicate log, to the specific times, to the 9 hours before my call at 4:30 a.m., to the nurse not being called until 3:10 a.m., and to the medication not being given until 4:05 a.m. Delaney conceded that the timeline looked poor in hindsight, but he insisted that hindsight was not intent. He said he had not set out to harm me, and that the jail had not set out to harm me. I believed, listening to him, that he might have believed that himself, and I also believed that belief did not erase the night I had spent in that cell.

Pruitt testified last among the defendants, and his testimony was that of a businessman defending a business rather than a deputy defending a badge. He was 53, of Pruitt's Towing, and he spoke about tow trucks, impound lots, storage fees, and invoices generated in a busy yard where paperwork was often completed late and sometimes duplicated by clerical error. He said the $590 impound charge and the $240 storage charge for my Tucson were standard, and that the $830 total was what I had paid to retrieve my car. He said the duplicate invoices totalling $49,000 were billing errors, not fraud, and that the cash handling issues reflected the informal way small towing operations sometimes dealt with property and payments at the roadside and at the lot. The prosecution cross-examined him on the pattern, on the repetition of the same errors, on the same vehicles and dates appearing twice, and on the connection between his towing contract and the sheriff's office. Pruitt maintained that repetition did not prove intent, that a busy business made the same mistake more than once, and that he had never intended to steal from motorists. The jury listened, and I noticed that the prosecution did not argue with his tone. They simply returned, again and again, to the documents, letting the invoices speak in a sequence that made coincidence sound increasingly unlikely.

In closing, the prosecution returned to the simplest structure they had used from the opening: a road, a time, a car, and a set of records that agreed with each other. The prosecutor reminded the jury of the full stop at the four-way stop at the empty crossroads, of both headlights working, of Louise Hart's dashcam, and of the telematics from my Tucson. The prosecutor reminded the jury of Carla Jensen's duplicate log, of the $850 omitted from the booking inventory, of the $590 impound charge and the $240 storage charge, and of the falsified tow inventory. The prosecutor reminded the jury of the 9 hours before my phone call at 4:30 a.m., of the nurse not called until 3:10 a.m., of the medication not given until 4:05 a.m., and of the 16 hours from 7:22 p.m. on Friday until 11:18 a.m. on Saturday. The prosecutor then widened the frame, as the evidence had widened it, to the 22 motorists over 2 years, to the $49,000 in duplicate Pruitt invoices, to the $36,200 in unlogged cash seizures, and to the $296,800 total scheme. The prosecutor said the defence wanted the jury to see a series of mistakes, but mistakes did not repeat themselves in the same direction, for the same benefit, across the same records, for two years. A mistake, the prosecutor said, was random. This was not random. This was a pattern, and a pattern was a choice.

The defence closed with an appeal to doubt, and it was a skilled appeal, even though I disagreed with every conclusion it drew. The defence reminded the jury that perception at dusk was uncertain, that dashcam angles and telematics interpretations could be debated, that booking logs were completed by tired people, and that tow billing was messy. The defence said Carla Jensen had kept a duplicate log for her own reasons, that Louise Hart had seen what she believed she had seen from behind, and that my own notes, written after my release, were reconstructions rather than contemporaneous records. The defence said the prosecution had taken a difficult night in a county jail and a set of billing disputes and had assembled them into a federal case that was larger than the facts. The defence asked the jury to hold the prosecution to its burden, to require proof beyond a reasonable doubt for each defendant and each charge, and to refuse to convict on sympathy, on pattern alone, or on a desire to send a message about policing in general. I listened to that closing and felt, for the first time in the trial, a genuine fear that doubt, carefully cultivated, might be enough, because doubt did not need to disprove every record. It only needed to make one juror hesitate on one charge.

News in the same category

What the Sheriff Took on Old Mill Road

45 Part