What the Sheriff Took on Old Mill Road

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

When Raman called with the news that federal charges were coming, she did not dress it up. She told me that a federal grand jury had returned an indictment against Sheriff Tom Beaumont, 60, Deputy Jesse Rooker, 32, jailer Deputy Hank Delaney, 49, and tow operator Marty Pruitt, 53, and she read the shape of the case to me in plain language, without legal flourishes, so that I would hear it before I read it in the news. The charges, as she explained them, centred on what had happened to me and on what the investigation had found beyond me: the deprivation of rights under colour of law in the stop, the arrest, and the detention; the falsification of records in the booking log and the tow inventory; and the taking of money and property that was never properly recorded. Beaumont was charged as the sheriff who directed the stop and who had allowed the pattern to continue in Blackwater County. Rooker was charged for his part in the stop and the arrest. Delaney was charged for his part in the booking and the detention. Pruitt was charged for the tow records and the money connected to the tows. I listened with the phone pressed to my ear and a pen in my hand, and I wrote down only the names, because the names were the part I needed to be certain I had right.

David sat with me that evening and went through what an indictment meant and what it did not mean. It did not mean a conviction. It did not mean the end of the waiting. It meant that prosecutors believed they could prove the case to a jury beyond a reasonable doubt, and that a grand jury had agreed there was enough to proceed. He warned me that the defence would not be a single argument but a series of small cuts, each one aimed at a different witness, a different record, a different memory, and that the trial would feel less like a single story told straight through and more like a story taken apart and put back together in front of strangers. He also told me that my job had not changed since the night I was stopped. My job was to tell the truth as I remembered it, in the order it happened, without adding anything to make it sound worse and without leaving anything out to make it sound easier. I had been doing that since I first wrote my notes, and I told him I could do it again in a courtroom.

My grandmother, Edith Whitfield, 79, heard the news from me in Tallahassee, and she was quiet for a long time before she answered. She had fallen at home in early October, and that fall was the reason I had been driving south in the first place, and she had carried a guilt about that trip that I had tried, more than once, to lift from her. She said she was glad the case was moving, and she said she did not want me to spend the trial thinking about her fall. I told her the trial was not about her fall. It was about what happened after I left Atlanta to reach her, and about whether a sheriff could use a badge to turn a quiet drive into a night in a cell. She accepted that, in the careful way she accepted most difficult things, and she asked me to call her after each day in court, not for the details, but so she would know I was steady. I promised her I would, and I kept that promise even on the days when steady felt like a performance I had to practise before I picked up the phone.

The months between the indictment and the trial were filled with preparation that looked, from the outside, like very little happening. Prosecutors met with me and went through my account line by line, asking me to explain the same moments in different words to see whether the facts stayed the same when the wording changed. They asked about the four-way stop at the empty crossroads on Old Mill Road, about the time, 7:22 p.m. on that Friday in early October, about the dusk light and the road and the position of my white 2020 Hyundai Tucson. They asked about the headlights, which I had checked before leaving Atlanta, and about the claim that one headlight was dim or out. They asked about my refusal of a warrantless search of my car, about the arrest for obstruction and disorderly conduct, about the confiscation of my phone at the roadside, and about the tow by Pruitt's Towing. They asked about the booking, about the $850 in my wallet for my grandmother's groceries and bills, about the $590 impound charge and the $240 storage charge, and about the hours in the cell. I answered in the same order every time, because that was the order in which it had happened, and I did not let myself rearrange it to make a better story.

News in the same category

What the Sheriff Took on Old Mill Road

45 Part