What the Sheriff Took on Old Mill Road

Chapter 39

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

In the weeks between the verdicts and the sentencing I tried to live as normally as I could, and that effort itself taught me something about what had happened to me, because normal life did not simply resume when a trial ended, it had to be rebuilt in small decisions, one at a time. I went back to my apartment in Atlanta and made my meals and answered my messages and kept my appointments, and I checked on my grandmother Edith Whitfield in Tallahassee by telephone, and I listened to her voice, which was stronger than it had been in the first days after her fall, and I let myself feel relief without pretending that relief was the same as resolution. David called often, not only as my brother but as my attorney, and he explained what a sentencing hearing would involve and what I would be asked to do if I chose to speak, and he never pressed me to speak, he only made sure I understood that the choice was mine and that whatever I said would become part of the record. I thought about that choice for a long time, and I thought about it the way I think about a treatment plan, by asking what it was meant to do and who it was meant to help, and I decided that I would speak, not to punish anyone with my voice, but to put into the record, in my own words, what a single night in a cell had cost, and what it had not taken from me. I wrote my statement the way I had written everything else, by hand first, and then I read it aloud to myself in my kitchen, and I crossed out any sentence that sounded like anger for its own sake, because anger had not been what kept me steady on Old Mill Road, and it had not been what kept me steady in the cell either. What had kept me steady was attention, and the habit of noticing exactly what was happening, and I wanted the court to hear that, because I wanted the sentence to be based on facts, not on the volume of anyone's feelings.

On the morning of the sentencing I dressed carefully, the way I had dressed for every other court date, in clothes that were plain and neat and that would not distract from what I had to say, and I drove with David to the courthouse and parked and walked in with my notebook in my bag, even though I knew I would probably not need to open it, because by then the important dates and times were fixed in my mind in a way that no longer required a page to hold them. The courtroom filled slowly, and I recognised faces I had come to know over the course of the investigation and the trial, including Carla Jensen, who sat with her hands folded and her eyes forward, and Louise Hart, who gave me a small nod when she saw me, and Agent Priya Raman, who was present in the quiet, professional way she had been present throughout, without any show of triumph. Sheriff Tom Beaumont entered with his attorney, and Deputy Jesse Rooker followed, and Jailer Deputy Hank Delaney and tow operator Marty Pruitt were brought in for their own parts of the proceedings, and I watched them without staring, because I had learned that watching carefully is not the same as watching for revenge, and I wanted to be able to remember this day accurately, not through a haze of feeling. The judge took the bench and spoke about the purpose of sentencing, and he spoke in measured language about accountability and about the trust that people place in a badge and in a jail log and in a tow yard, and about what happens to that trust when it is used as a tool for taking rather than for protecting, and I listened to every word, because I had waited a long time to hear an authority in that room describe what had happened to me without minimising it.

When it was my turn to speak I stood and walked to the place where witnesses stand, and I felt the familiar tightening in my chest that I had felt on the roadside and in the cell, and I breathed the way I teach children to breathe when they are frightened by a new exercise, slowly and without rushing, and I looked at the judge and not at the men who had harmed me, because I wanted my words to be addressed to the court and to the record, not to a confrontation. I said my name, Amara Whitfield, and I said that I was thirty-six years old and a pediatric physical therapist in Atlanta, and that I had been travelling alone to Tallahassee to see my grandmother Edith Whitfield, who was seventy-nine and had recently fallen at home, and I said that I had stopped fully at the four-way stop on Old Mill Road and that both of my headlights had been working, and that I had politely declined a warrantless search of my car, and that I had then been arrested for obstruction and disorderly conduct. I described, without embellishment, the confiscation of my phone at the roadside, the towing of my white 2020 Hyundai Tucson by Pruitt's Towing, the omission of eight hundred and fifty dollars from the booking inventory, the denial of a phone call for nine hours, the holding of my purse with my daily blood-pressure medication inside it, the pounding headache and the rising panic and the nosebleed in the cell, the fact that a jail nurse was not called until three ten in the morning, and the fact that my medication was finally given at four five in the morning, and I described my release at eleven eighteen on Saturday morning with a citation that was later dropped. I did not raise my voice, and I did not ask the court for cruelty, and I said plainly that I was asking for sentences that would make it clear that a badge does not place a person above the law, and that a jail log is not a private story that can be rewritten, and that a tow truck is not a way to punish a traveller for saying no to a search. I thanked Carla Jensen and Louise Hart without naming them as heroes, because they had not asked to be heroes, they had simply kept records and told the truth, and I thanked my brother David for driving down to Cypress Springs when I finally reached him, and I sat down feeling steadier than I had expected, because I had said what was true and I had not said more than was true.

News in the same category

What the Sheriff Took on Old Mill Road

45 Part