Who Belongs Here

Chapter 16

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“What did the guidance say?”

“It said that Reserve members’ seating preferences in rows one and two should be honored wherever possible.” Diane paused. “It came from the regional office. Mr. Hollister sent it to all the cabin leads on the East Coast routes. And then in March there was a follow-up, after one of the members complained that she’d been seated in row four. That one said that member retention was the single most important metric for the Reserve pilot, and that cabin leads would be evaluated in part on Reserve satisfaction scores.”

“Wherever possible,” Vivian repeated.

“Yes, ma’am.”

“And you took that to mean you could move a passenger out of a confirmed seat.”

Diane hesitated. Constance watched her decide whether to lie and decide against it.

“I took it to mean that I should do whatever I could to make the members happy,” Diane said. “Including asking other passengers to accommodate them. Most people don’t mind, Ms. Morgan. You offer them a different seat and a glass of champagne and they’re perfectly fine. People understand how these things work. I’ve been doing this for twenty-two years. I’ve flown heads of state and movie stars and men who owned half of Connecticut. There have always been people who get the good seat. That’s not something Halcyon invented.”

“No,” said Vivian. “It isn’t.”

She was quiet for a moment, looking at Diane, and Constance, watching her, thought that she did not look angry. She looked tired, suddenly, and older than she had a moment ago, and very sad.

“Did you fly the Nantucket route in April?” Vivian asked. “The eleventh. Flight 241, the afternoon departure.”

Diane’s face changed. It was a small change, a tightening around the eyes and mouth, but Constance had spent fifty years reading faces across dinner tables and she saw it clearly, and she saw that Vivian saw it too.

“I believe so, yes.”

“Was Elena Marsh working that flight with you?”

The silence lasted perhaps two seconds.

“Yes, ma’am. She was.”

“She wrote to me,” Vivian said. “She resigned in May and three weeks ago she wrote me a letter. A real letter, by hand. She told me what happened on that flight. A passenger who wouldn’t give up his seat to a Reserve member. She told me what you said to her afterward in the galley.” Vivian’s voice did not rise. “Something about the difference between rules and relationships.”

Diane’s chin came up. “Ms. Morgan, with respect, Elena was very young and very idealistic, and she didn’t understand that—“

“She was twenty-six,” said Vivian. “She’d been with us for nineteen months, and her performance reviews were excellent, and she quit because she loved the job too much to watch it turn into something she didn’t believe in. That’s what I understand, Diane. I’ve read the letter twenty times. I’m not asking you to agree with her. I’m telling you she wrote it.”

Diane did not answer.

Behind her, in the aisle, Sofia Reyes had gone very still. Constance glanced at the girl and saw that her eyes were bright, and that she was pressing her lips together hard, the way young women do when they are trying not to cry in public and are determined not to let anyone see. Constance had done that herself, many years ago. She had not done it in a long time.

“Sofia,” said Vivian, without turning around. “Did you know Elena?”

“Yes, ma’am.” The girl’s voice wobbled and then steadied. “We trained together. She was the reason I applied the third time, after they turned me down twice. She told me to keep trying.”

“Have you ever been asked to move a passenger for a Reserve member?”

Sofia looked at Diane. Diane did not look back.

“Once, ma’am. In May. On the Aspen route. A man had booked 1A and a Reserve member wanted it. I asked the man if he’d mind moving and he said no, he didn’t mind.” She swallowed. “He was very nice about it. He was in a wheelchair. He’d chosen 1A because it was closest to the door. It took us ten minutes to get him into 3A, and he had to use the aisle chair, and everyone was watching. He kept saying it was fine. I went to the lavatory afterward and—“ She stopped.

Vivian turned and looked at her. For a moment no one said anything.

“Thank you for telling me,” Vivian said quietly. “I’m sorry you had to do that.”

“It was my job,” said Sofia.

“No,” said Vivian. “It wasn’t. That’s the point.”

She turned back to the cabin, and Constance saw her draw a breath and let it out slowly, the way a swimmer does before going under.

“I’d like everyone to understand something,” Vivian said. “Diane didn’t invent this policy. She didn’t write the guidance from the regional office, and she didn’t set the metrics she’s evaluated on. Those came from the company. The Reserve program came to my board in January, and I approved it. I read the phrase preferred access to the first two rows, and I thought it meant something harmless, and I didn’t ask what it would mean on an aircraft on a Friday morning when someone wanted a seat that wasn’t theirs. That’s my failure, not hers. I’m the one whose name is at the top. Whatever happened on this aircraft today, and in April, and in May, happened because of a decision I signed.”

Tags #Stories

News in the same category

Who Belongs Here

30 Part