Who Belongs Here

Chapter 18

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“You told me this row was for people who belong here,” Vivian said. “I’d like to know how you decided I didn’t.”

Constance had been asked difficult questions before. She had been asked by a lawyer, in a paneled office in Boston, whether she had known about her husband’s debts. She had been asked by her daughter, at the age of fifteen, whether she had ever actually loved Daddy or had only married the name. She had been asked by a priest at her son’s funeral whether she would like to say a few words, and she had stood up and said none, because there were none.

She had always known how to answer a difficult question. You chose the version of the truth that cost the least, and you said it in a voice that did not invite a second question. It was a skill, like riding or bridge, and she had practiced it for half a century.

She opened her mouth to do it now, and found that nothing came.

Captain Brooks had gone back to the flight deck, and she could hear his voice faintly through the open cockpit door, speaking on the phone. The cabin had settled into an uneasy quiet. Some of the passengers had turned back to their phones or their windows, out of tact or embarrassment, but most of them were still listening, and Constance could feel their attention on the back of her neck the way one feels the sun.

“I didn’t decide anything,” she said at last. “Diane told me there had been an error with the seat. I assumed you would be given another one.”

“That’s true,” said Vivian. “That’s what Diane told you. But that isn’t what you said to me.”

Constance looked down at the fan.

“No,” she said. “It isn’t.”

“I’m not trying to humiliate you,” said Vivian. “I want you to know that. I’ve already embarrassed you in front of a cabin full of people, and I’m sorry for that part of it. I didn’t do it to punish you. I did it because I’d just watched my company do something I’d spent three weeks hoping it wouldn’t, and I needed to stop it right then, before it took off and became normal again. But you’re the one who said the words. So I’d like to understand them. That’s all.”

Constance was silent for a long moment.

She thought about the lounge, an hour ago. She thought about the woman in the corner, watching her, and what she had seen when she looked back. The linen. The sandals. The absence of jewelry. The plain black coffee. She thought about what she had concluded, and how quickly, and how certain she had been, and she felt something hot rise in her face that she did not at first recognize, because it had been so long since she had felt it. It was shame.

“I looked at you,” she said slowly, “and I didn’t see anything I recognized. You weren’t wearing anything that told me who you were. You weren’t with anyone I knew. You were sitting by yourself in the corner drinking black coffee and watching everyone. I thought—“ She stopped.

“Go on.”

“I thought you were someone’s assistant. Or a nanny. Or one of those young women who work in fashion and wear expensive clothes that look like nothing.” Constance made herself look up. “I thought you were someone who had gotten into that seat by accident, or on someone else’s money, and that you would be grateful to be moved somewhere else and given a glass of champagne. I didn’t think about it very much. That’s the truth. I didn’t think you were worth thinking about.”

Vivian did not react. She simply waited.

“And yes,” said Constance, more quietly, “I saw that you were—“ She hesitated, and felt the hot shame climb higher. “I saw your skin. I won’t pretend I didn’t. I don’t know whether it made any difference. I would like to think it didn’t. But I’m seventy-two years old and I was raised in Greenwich in the nineteen-fifties, and I don’t think I’m in a position to swear to you that it didn’t.”

There was a silence in the row.

Then, from behind them, a deep, slow voice said, “That’s the most honest thing I’ve heard anyone say on an airplane in forty years.”

Constance turned in her seat. So did Vivian.

The elderly man with the white beard had risen from the single seat in row five and was standing in the aisle, holding the back of the seat in front of him for balance. He was tall and very thin, in a linen jacket the color of oatmeal and a pale blue shirt, and his skin was dark, almost black, against the white of his beard. He had a long, grave face and eyes that were creased deeply at the corners, as if he had spent a lifetime finding things funny and keeping quiet about it.

Tags #Stories

News in the same category

Who Belongs Here

30 Part