“Forgive me,” he said. “I’ve been eavesdropping, which is a terrible habit, but I’ve had a lot of practice. My name is Samuel Okafor. I’m a retired cardiac surgeon. I spent thirty-five years at Mass General and I’ve been flying back and forth to the islands since before either of you were born, Ms. Morgan, though perhaps not before you were, madam.” He inclined his head to Constance with old-fashioned courtesy. “May I say something?”
“Please,” said Vivian.
Dr. Okafor nodded slowly.
“I have been asked if I was in the right seat,” he said, “more times than I can count. In first class, in business class, on the shuttle to New York, on this airline, once, about two years ago, before the young lady here had joined.” He nodded toward Sofia. “Not by anyone rude. Never by anyone rude. It was always very polite. Excuse me, sir, may I see your boarding pass? Just checking, sir. We sometimes have mix-ups. Once, at Logan, a flight attendant asked me if I was the gentleman who needed help with the wheelchair, because there was a Black man on the manifest who needed help with the wheelchair, and I was a Black man. I was wearing a suit. I was on my way to give a keynote at a conference on valve replacement. I said no, I was not that gentleman, and she apologized very sweetly, and I sat down in my seat, and for the whole flight to Chicago I could not stop thinking about it.”
He paused.
“I don’t tell you this to make anyone feel badly,” he said. “I tell you because the lady was honest, and I think honesty deserves a reply. She said she couldn’t swear it made no difference. I appreciate that. Most people swear it. Most people swear it so quickly that you know they’ve never once asked themselves the question.” He looked at Constance. “You asked yourself. That’s a start. It’s more than most.”
Constance stared at him. She did not know what to say. She found that her eyes were stinging.
“Thank you, Dr. Okafor,” said Vivian quietly.
“Not at all.” The old man smiled suddenly, a wide, warm, entirely unexpected smile that changed his whole face. “And may I say, Ms. Morgan, that I knew your father. Not well. We sat together once on one of his first flights out of Opa-locka, in a King Air with no air conditioning and a broken seat belt, in nineteen ninety-something. He spent the whole flight telling me how he was going to build an airline where nobody ever had to ask anybody if they were in the right seat. I thought he was a lunatic. I’ve been flying with you ever since.” He settled himself back into his seat, slowly, and picked up his newspaper. “Please carry on. I just wanted to say that.”
There was a small, startled ripple of laughter in the cabin, and then, from the back, the young mother with the baby began to clap, uncertainly, and then one of the newlyweds joined her, and then, to Constance’s astonishment, the young man in the hoodie, and for a few seconds there was a scattered, embarrassed applause that faded almost as soon as it began. Dr. Okafor raised one hand without looking up from his paper, acknowledging it, and turned a page.
Vivian turned back to Constance. She was smiling slightly.
“I didn’t know that,” she said. “About my father. He never told me.”
“He seems to have told a great many people a great many things,” said Constance, and was surprised to hear something like warmth in her own voice.
“He talked to everybody,” said Vivian. “That was his secret. He talked to the mechanics and the fuel truck drivers and the people who cleaned the lavatories, and he talked to the passengers, all of them, the rich ones and the ones who’d saved up for a year to fly with us once. He said if you only talked to the people at the top, you’d only ever hear the version of the truth that cost them the least.”
Constance flinched very slightly. She did not think Vivian could possibly have known what she had been thinking a few minutes ago, about the version of the truth that cost the least. But the words landed in the same place, and stung.
“May I tell you something?” Vivian said.
“Yes.”
“My mother was a flight attendant. Before she met my father. For eleven years. On one of the big airlines, in first class, in the days when they weighed the girls every month and fired them if they put on six pounds.” Vivian’s voice was even and unhurried. “Once, on a flight to New York, a man in first class hit her across the face with a rolled-up newspaper because she didn’t bring him a second steak fast enough. Everybody on the plane saw it. He was an important man. Nobody said anything. Not the captain, not the purser, not the other passengers. My mother says they all looked out the window.”
Constance said nothing.