skin, in a bottle, in a row with eight other Wednesdays. You used to write on
my tests, careful work is its own testimony." She wiped her face with the
heel of her hand. "I wasn't careful work. I was just work she could sign
someone else's name to."
She agreed, before she left the porch, to all of it: the notebook and the
screenshots to Detective Kim, the three guests' names, the totals, the
48
sentences Val had said about the records, in any room it was needed in,
including rooms with Val in them. Walter walked her to the sidewalk, an old
man and a young woman in the streetlight, and Colin heard him say, at the
distance of the gate, "Precision, Rebecca," and heard her answer, steady
enough, "Yes, sir."
The smear arrived the following week wearing the costume smears wear in
Heron Bay: concern. It moved through the swim-team widows first โ the
eight o'clock lane circle at the club pool, women Colin had known by sight
for a decade, widows several of them, who took their exercise with the
discipline of a tide table โ and then into the neighborhood group chat, where
it acquired the italics of forwarding. The substance of it was that Colin Avery
filmed women in his pool. That the cameras were his hobby. That a man who
bottles his own water is a man with an interest, and that decent people should
ask what the interest was, and whether daughters and granddaughters should
be at neighborhood events where he was present with a phone in his pocket.
It was a filthy little masterpiece of a rumor, Colin thought, reading it in a
screenshot Benson sent him without comment, because it used the true
skeleton โ there were cameras, there was footage, there were women โ and
put a predator's face on it, and because it was the only move left on Val's side
of the board that did not require her to explain a cooler, a mileage log, or a
guest book.
Benson's answer was a single letter to the board, one page, with two
attachments, and its restraint was its power. The letter stated facts and
declined, in terms, to do anything else. The camera on the Avery property
had been installed in 2021 by a licensed contractor at the requirement of the
Avery homeowner's insurer, following a break-in at the pool shed in which
equipment was stolen; its field of view covered the gate and the shed door, as
49
the insurer's specification required and as the attached installation certificate
attested; it did not cover the pool. No other camera existed on the property.
All footage from the device, unedited and complete, had been surrendered to
the Savannah Police Department, where it remained; Mr. Avery retained no
copies beyond those furnished to his counsel. Any member of the association
was welcome to direct questions to the insurer, the installer, or Detective
Sarah Kim. The letter concluded with a sentence that Colin read three times
for the pleasure of its temperature: My client does not respond to anonymous
communications, but he keeps them.
Two of the whisperers came to him in person, at the mailbox, within days of
each other โ a lane-swimmer who had forwarded the message to her sister
with a can-you-imagine attached, and who now stood in the street's gold
evening light and said she had not asked the first question a person should
ask, which was whether it was true, and that she was sorry; and a second
woman, blunter, who said Val had repeated it at the club as established fact,
with the air of a person doing a public service, and that she had believed it
because believing Val had been the neighborhood's habit for fifteen years,
and habits were not evidence, and she was sorry about that too. Colin
thanked them both and meant it. He had lived in Heron Bay long enough to
know what it cost a person to walk down a driveway and unsay a thing, and
he understood, watching them go, that the letter had not won an argument. It
had done something slower and more structural: it had given the
neighborhood a second source. For fifteen years there had been one source,
and her name was on the meeting notices.
Detective Kim came by on the Friday of that week and took coffee on Colin's
deck and looked at the pool for a while without saying anything, the way
investigators do when the scene has already given up everything it's going to.
50
The district attorney was preparing charges, she said: trespass, breaking and
entering as to the gate, theft of services, and fraud โ fraud against the three
guests, who had paid for a program that did not exist, and fraud against the
association, whose funds had bought the floats and the mileage to reach
them. Becca's notebook had come in and was, in Kim's word, beautiful โ
"she kept the book like a hostage taking notes," Kim said, "dates, houses,
amounts, and little stars next to the Wednesdays Val took a guest's cash in an
envelope instead. The DA is going to frame that notebook." But the timeline
was the DA's, she warned him, and it ran in weeks, not days: a grand jury to