carried that carton into the courtroom herself, and she had told Colin once, in
an interview room, that it was the cleanest chain of evidence she had ever
been handed β that most cases were built out of what people said, and his
was built out of what the water had kept.
74
The prosecutor took his sixty seconds to explain it to the room, and he did it
well, the way a man does a thing he has rehearsed in a mirror. A pool, he
said, keeps everything that enters it. It keeps the sunscreen and the
champagne and the skin of strangers; it keeps the chemical signature of every
body that has been in it, in loadings a competent man with a test kit can read
like a guest register. Mr. Avery was a competent man with a test kit, and he
had kept his register for twenty years without knowing he was keeping it. On
the Wednesdays when Mr. Avery was three counties away with his route, his
water testified that his pool had company β how much company, and on
which dates, and in one memorable sample, that someone had thoughtfully
shocked it afterward to cover the arithmetic, which is not a thing water
forgets either. The water, the prosecutor said, resting his hand on the carton,
did not have an opinion about Mrs. Kessler. It simply declined to lie for her.
Colin watched Val while the clerk read. She listened the way a person listens
to weather in another county β attentively, and without any power over it β
and when the reading was done the judge leaned forward on her forearms.
Judge Anita Coleman had a face that gave nothing away as a matter of
professional design, and she asked the only question the morning had been
built to hold: whether the summary, as read, was true in substance.
Val said, "It is," so quietly that the court reporter looked up from her
machine and asked, with the terrible courtesy of her profession, whether the
witness would repeat that for the record.
Val repeated it. It cost her more the second time, and Colin β who had come
prepared to feel something large and simple β found instead that he felt
something small and complicated, which was almost pity, and he set it aside
to examine later, the way he set aside any reading he didn't yet trust.
The sentence came down the way sentences do, in the grammar of
75
conditions. Three years' probation. Restitution in full, as ordered by the court
β the defrauded guests repaid through the clerk's office, the eleven rotation
households made whole for the use of what was theirs, the association
reimbursed for every dollar of its money that had ever bought a shrimp ring.
Two hundred hours of community service, to be served cleaning and
maintaining the county's community pool, under the supervision of the parks
department. And the letters: handwritten letters of apology to each of the
eleven households, filed through the probation office before the first of
December β a condition, the judge said, not a suggestion.
Judge Coleman looked over her glasses for the last of it. "Mrs. Kessler," she
said, "you have demonstrated a genuine enthusiasm for other people's pools.
The county will help you redirect it." She brought the gavel down once,
without emphasis, like a woman closing a book she had not enjoyed, and the
Wednesday Club was over in the eyes of the law.
There was one more formality. The judge, before she excused the room,
asked whether the homeowner wished to be heard β the victim's statement,
a right the clerk had explained to Colin in a pamphlet months ago and that he
had been declining in his mind ever since, in draft after draft, all of them too
long or too short or too hot. He stood because Laura's hand was briefly at his
elbow, and he found that the drafts burned off and what remained was eleven
words, which he delivered to the judge and, unavoidably, to the woman at the
defense table. "The water already said everything I had, Your Honor. I'd just
be repeating it." Judge Coleman inclined her head the fraction she allowed
herself, and Val β who had not looked at him once in the whole proceeding,
who had kept her eyes on the clerk and the flag and the middle distance like a
woman reading a tide table β looked at him then, directly, for the first and
last time in that room, and what he saw was not defiance and not appeal but
76
the plain, exhausted recognition of one record-keeper by another. He sat
down. Laura's pad was still blank. It stayed blank all the way home.
The rest of them were disposed of across the same two weeks, in smaller
rooms, without cartons of anything. Marcia Dunn pleaded to a misdemeanor
trespass and took her probation and her fine standing very straight, with Ron
behind her chair and her coat over his arm both mornings β a man holding a
garment the way a man holds a job he has been demoted to and intends, this
time, to do well. Lorraine Faye and Gwen Park signed their cooperation
agreements and paid their fines and their shares of the restitution and did not