He left the house then, into the cold, and he walked for hours through snow that had begun to fall again, through streets that were quiet and lit only by porch lights and the occasional passing car. He walked until his anger cooled into something colder and more familiar: shame. He thought about going back. He thought about knocking on his own front door and saying, simply, that he was sorry, that he had not meant it, that his father was right to worry and that he, Elias, was right to dream, and that both things could be true at the same time. He rehearsed the apology in his mind, turning it over like a sketch, revising it, making it better, making it perfect. He told himself he would say it in the morning, when tempers had cooled and the kitchen was warm again and his father was sitting at the table with coffee, ready to listen.
He did not know that there would be no morning like that.
The next day began ordinarily, which is the cruelest way for a terrible day to begin. Elias woke late in his room, his coat still damp from the night before, his head aching from cold and from lack of sleep. He could hear his mother in the kitchen, moving quietly, and Clara in her room, playing music too softly to make out the song. He could hear his father getting ready to leave, the familiar sounds of boots and keys and a coat being pulled on, and he lay in bed and told himself that he would get up in a moment, that he would go downstairs and say the apology he had rehearsed, that it would be awkward for a minute and then it would be over, the way arguments in families are supposed to be over.
He did not get up in time. He heard the front door close, and he heard his father’s car start, and he told himself that he would catch him at supper, that one more day of waiting would not matter, that his father was not going anywhere except to work and back. He went to his classes, and he drew buildings, and he tried to concentrate, and he failed, and he came home in the afternoon to a house that was already different, though he did not know it yet.
Margaret was sitting at the kitchen table when he came in, and she was not cooking, and she was not reading, and she was not doing any of the things she usually did in the late afternoon. She was sitting very still, with her hands folded in front of her, and Clara was sitting beside her, crying quietly into her sleeve, and there was a policeman standing by the door with his hat in his hands, speaking in the low, careful voice people use when they are delivering news that will change the shape of a family forever.
Thomas Hart had been in a traffic accident on his way to work, on a road made slick by ice and by a driver who had been going too fast for the conditions. It had not been anyone’s fault in the way Elias wanted fault to work, with a single person to blame and a single mistake to point to. It had been weather and speed and timing, a series of small, ordinary failures that had added up to something irreversible. He had died before the ambulance arrived, the policeman said, and he had not suffered, though Elias did not know how anyone could know that for certain, and he did not believe it, not then, not for a long time.
Elias stood in the doorway with his coat still on, snow melting on his boots and pooling on the floor, and he felt the world tilt, not dramatically, but quietly, as if the floor had shifted a fraction of an inch and would never quite be level again. He heard his mother say his name, and he heard Clara sob, and he heard himself say, “No,” once, very quietly, as if saying it could undo what had been said. It could not. The policeman left, and the house filled with the sounds of people trying to be kind: neighbors bringing food, friends calling, the telephone ringing and ringing, and underneath it all, the silence where his father’s voice should have been.
That night, Elias sat in his father’s workshop, surrounded by tools that still smelled of wood and oil, and he held his father’s old brass compass in his hands, the one Thomas had used for drawing circles and for measuring, the one he had let Elias play with when Elias was small and had promised him, one day, when he was older. The compass was cool and heavy, and it fit in his palm the way a familiar object does, and Elias turned it over and over, thinking about the argument at the kitchen table, thinking about the words he had said about being smaller, about being believed in, about needing to be somewhere else. He thought about the apology he had rehearsed and never delivered, and the thought grew in him like a weight, pressing down on his chest until it was hard to breathe.
He blamed himself, not logically, but completely. He knew, in the rational part of his mind, that his argument had not caused the accident, that ice and speed had caused it, that his father would have driven to work that morning whether they had argued or not. But grief does not listen to logic, and guilt is a more obedient companion than reason. Guilt told him a simpler story: he had hurt his father, and then his father had died, and the hurt had never been repaired, and therefore he was responsible, not for the crash, but for the last thing his father had heard from him. He had left his father with anger, and anger, in the story guilt told, was a kind of leaving, and leaving, if it was not repaired, became permanent.