At the library, the air was warmer and smelled of old paper and floor polish, and the woman at the community board, a librarian Margaret had known for years, took the flyers without making a fuss of it. "I'll put one on the board and one by the computers," she said. "People linger there. They actually look." She paused, then added, in a lower voice, "Any news, Margaret?"
Margaret wanted to say no, and leave it at that, but the librarian's kindness loosened something in her. "No news," she said. "Only the same hope, carried a little further. Clara keeps telling me to stop coming in the snow. She says I'll catch cold. She says I should let the shelters do their work."
"And what do you say to her?" the librarian asked.
"I say that a mother does not stop looking because it is snowing," Margaret said, and was surprised by the steadiness in her own voice. "I say that if he is out there in this weather, then I can be out here for an hour, in a warm coat, with a friend beside me. That seems like a fair trade."
The librarian nodded, and pinned the flyer with a careful thumb, straightening it twice, and Margaret felt an absurd gratitude for that small act of care, for a stranger treating her son's face as if it mattered. On the way out, she stopped at the window and watched the snow falling over the street, and she thought about Clara, who was twenty-four now and worked in a bakery and had her mother's stubbornness and her father's practical hands. Clara had been the one, in the early years, who cried herself to sleep and asked when Elias was coming home, and then, as she grew older, had stopped asking, not because she had stopped caring, but because she had learned that asking hurt her mother in a way she could see. Margaret had always regretted that silence. She had wanted Clara to keep asking. She had wanted someone, anyone, to keep saying his name out loud in the house, so that he would not fade into a photograph on a table.
Her phone buzzed as they reached the car, and it was Clara, as if the thought itself had called her. "Mum," Clara said, and Margaret could hear the bakery behind her, the clatter of trays and the low hum of the ovens. "Are you out in this snow again?"
"I am out, and I am perfectly warm," Margaret said, smiling despite herself. "Ruth is with me. We are being sensible. Are you all right?"
"I'm all right," Clara said, but there was a hesitation in her voice, the kind Margaret had learned to hear even over a bad connection. "It's just, there's a man, Mum. In the alley behind the bakery. He's been there for days. He doesn't beg, exactly. He just sits there, against the wall, and I gave him a sandwich yesterday, and then again today, and he looked at me like nobody had ever done that before. I don't know why I'm telling you. I suppose because I keep thinking about Elias, and about how someone, somewhere, might have given him a sandwich once, when he needed it, and I never got to thank them."
Margaret stood very still in the snow, the phone pressed to her ear, while Ruth waited by the car with the engine running. The bakery. The alley. A man who did not beg, who sat against a wall, who looked stunned by kindness. It was not evidence. Margaret knew that. There were many men in many alleys in Chicago, and most of them were not Elias. She had chased too many almosts over ten years to let herself believe in a story told over the phone. And yet her heart, which had learned to be careful, began to beat faster anyway, not with certainty, but with something older and more stubborn than certainty: recognition, or the wish for it.
"Clara," she said, keeping her voice even, "what does he look like?"
Clara laughed a little, embarrassed. "Thin. Tired. A beard. An old black coat. I don't know, Mum. He could be anyone. He doesn't talk much. He said his name was Eli, or something like that, but I don't think that's his real name. He looks like he's trying not to take up too much space in the world, if that makes sense."
Eli. Margaret closed her eyes. Elias had been called Eli once, by his friends at school, and by Clara herself when she was small and could not manage the whole name. Eli, Eli, come and see. The sound of it, after ten years, was like a door opening in a house she thought she had locked.
"It makes sense," Margaret said softly. "It makes perfect sense. Clara, love, will you do something for me? Will you keep giving him sandwiches? And will you not go into the alley alone after dark? I don't want you to be frightened, I only want you to be safe, and I want to come and see the bakery district for myself, with Ruth, tomorrow, if the snow lets us. Not to frighten him. Only to look. Only to be near, in case."
"Of course I'll keep giving him sandwiches," Clara said, and Margaret could hear the stubbornness in her daughter's voice, the same stubbornness that had made her give a sandwich to a stranger in the first place. "And of course you can come. You don't have to ask. The bakery is warm. You can sit by the window and drink tea and pretend you're not looking. I'll pretend I don't notice."