A Sandwich in Winter

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Eli took them and turned them over in his hands. “You don’t have to do this,” he said again, but his voice was softer this time, less like a refusal and more like a question he was asking himself.

“I know,” Clara said, and she sat down again, on the step, pulling her beige puffer coat tighter around her. “My mother says I take on strays. She says it like it’s a character flaw, but she does the same thing, so I don’t take it seriously.”

Eli looked at her then, really looked at her, and Clara felt, for a second, as if he were seeing someone else standing beside her, or behind her, a ghost of a person she could not see. “Your mother sounds kind,” he said.

“She worries,” Clara said. “She worries about everyone. She worries about me, about the bakery, about the weather, about people she hasn’t seen in years. Sometimes I think worrying is how she loves people. It’s exhausting, and it’s also—” She searched for the word. “It’s also how I know she’s still there, I guess. Even when she’s being impossible.”

Eli nodded, slowly, as if he were storing the sentence away. “My mother—” he began, and then he stopped, and took a sip of soup to cover the stop. “I mean, mothers are like that, aren’t they?”

Clara laughed, but it was a small laugh, not quite easy. “Mine especially. She lost—” She paused, and the pause was different from his pause, heavier, as if she were deciding how much to tell a stranger in an alley in the rain. “She lost someone, a long time ago. My brother. He left home when I was little, and he never came back. She still looks for him, in a way. Not with flyers anymore, not really, but she looks. She notices men on the street, she notices—” Clara stopped herself. She did not know why she was telling him this. She had not meant to. The words had simply come out, the way words sometimes do when the rain is falling and a stranger is listening without interrupting. “I barely remember him, honestly. I remember a voice, and a scar, and someone who used to carry me on his shoulders. The rest is just photographs.”

Eli went very still. Clara noticed it because he had been moving, in small ways, all along: shifting his weight, turning the cup in his hands, brushing snow from his coat. Now he was still, as if the rain itself had stopped for a moment. His hand, the left one, tightened around the cup, and Clara saw, without meaning to look, the pale crescent on his wrist, just below his sleeve. She did not think anything of it then. A scar was a scar. People who lived outside had scars. She only noticed that his knuckles had gone white.

“I’m sorry,” he said, after a moment, and his voice was rough, as if the words had to climb out of somewhere deep. “That’s a hard thing to carry. For you, and for her.”

Clara shrugged, a small, practiced shrug she had learned as a child, when adults asked about her brother and she did not know what to say. “It’s old,” she said. “It’s just part of our family, like the house, like the bakery. Sometimes I forget about it for weeks. Sometimes I think about it and wonder if he’s alive, if he’s warm, if he ever thinks about us. And then I feel guilty for wondering, because wondering doesn’t help anyone.”

“It helps,” Eli said quietly. “Wondering means you haven’t given up.”

Clara looked at him, surprised by the certainty in his voice. “Do you speak from experience?”

He smiled, but it did not reach his eyes. “I speak from a lot of cold nights,” he said. “You learn things on cold nights. Mostly you learn that people remember more than they think they do, and less than they wish they did.”

They sat in the rain for a while after that, not talking much, and Clara found that the silence was not awkward. It was companionable, in a strange way, like sitting with someone you have known longer than you have. She told him, later, about the bakery in the morning, about the way the ovens warmed the whole shop before dawn, about the first customer who always asked for extra butter. He told her, in return, small stories, carefully chosen, like stones picked up and examined before being put down again. He told her about a man he had known who could fix anything with wire and tape, about a library where he used to read when it was too cold to be outside, about learning to draw buildings when he was young and believing, for a while, that lines on paper could become places where people lived. He did not tell her his last name. He did not tell her where he was from. He did not tell her about a compass in his pocket, or a father who had died, or a house he had left in the dark. He told her just enough to be a person, and not enough to be found, and Clara, who was stubborn but not foolish, understood that there were parts of his story he was not ready to tell, and she did not push.

News in the same category

A Sandwich in Winter

45 Part