"I keep thinking," she said, and then stopped, because she did not want to sound like the other mothers she had met in waiting rooms, the ones who told the same story over and over until it wore thin. But Daniel waited, without impatience, and so she went on. "I keep thinking he might not look like the photograph anymore. He might have a beard. He might be thinner. If someone sees him and thinks, no, that can't be the boy in the picture, they'll walk right past."
Daniel looked at the photograph for a long moment. "We don't only look for the picture, Mrs. Hart," he said quietly. "We look for the story. The age, the height, the scar. You told us about the scar on his wrist, remember? The crescent one. That's the kind of detail people remember, even when a face changes."
Margaret's breath caught, just a little, at the word scar. She had not forgotten it. How could she? She had been there, or almost there, on the day he got it, running down the snowy hill after him with her heart in her throat, and she had held his small wrist in the kitchen afterwards while Thomas cleaned the cut and told him, with a steadiness she envied, that brave boys sometimes bled a little. Elias had been nine, and Clara four, and the bicycle had been too big for her, and he had thrown himself in front of it without thinking, the way he did everything in those days, all heart and no plan. The scar had healed into a pale crescent, like a small moon on his skin, and for years Margaret had traced it with her finger when he fell asleep on the sofa, as if it were a secret only the two of them shared.
"I wrote it on the back," she said, turning the flyer over, although she knew Daniel already knew. "Left wrist. Crescent-shaped. From childhood."
"I know," Daniel said. "It's in our notes. Every new volunteer gets told. I promise you that."
Ruth, who had been standing a little behind Margaret, put a hand on her shoulder then, and Margaret realized her own hand was shaking. She folded it into her coat pocket, where it could shake in private. She thanked Daniel, and left a bag of cough drops on the desk, and as they walked back out into the snow she felt the familiar mixture that always followed these visits: a small, stubborn hope, and a larger, quieter ache, side by side, like two people walking together who did not speak the same language.
In the car, Ruth turned the heater up and did not ask Margaret if she was all right, which Margaret appreciated more than she could say. Instead, Ruth said, "Tell me about the last time you saw him, properly. Not the argument. The time before that."
Margaret stared out at the snow-covered street, at the salt trucks and the people hurrying with their collars up, and for a moment she was afraid she would not be able to answer. The memories had become like photographs left out in the sun; some were sharp, some had faded at the edges. But then one came back whole, the way a song sometimes comes back whole after years of forgetting it. It was a summer evening, not winter at all, and Elias was sitting at the kitchen table with a ruler and a pencil, drawing a house that did not exist yet, a house with wide windows and a porch that caught the afternoon light. Thomas had been reading the newspaper, and Clara had been colouring at the other end of the table, and Elias had looked up and said, "What if a house could make people kinder, just by the way the light comes in?" Thomas had laughed, not unkindly, and said that was a big job for a house, and Elias had grinned, that old grin, and said he liked big jobs.
"He wanted to build things that helped people," Margaret said, her voice thick. "That was all he ever wanted. Not money. Not praise. Just rooms where people could breathe easier. I think that's what he argued about with his father, in the end. Not whether he should build, but how, and for whom, and whether he was allowed to dream that big when the world was so practical."
Ruth nodded, keeping her eyes on the road. "And then his father died, and he thought the argument was the last thing they'd ever said to each other."
"Yes," Margaret said. "And I let him think that, for a while, because I was grieving too, and I didn't have the words. I told myself he'd come back when he'd had time. I told myself young men need to wander. I didn't know that wandering could last ten years. I didn't know that guilt could turn into a kind of home, a cold one, that a person stops trying to leave."
They drove in silence for a while after that, the windshield wipers pushing snow aside in steady arcs. Margaret watched the city go by, the shopfronts and the bus stops and the alleys that opened like dark mouths between buildings, and she thought about all the alleys she had walked down in ten years, all the doorways she had peered into, all the men she had approached with a photograph and a trembling hope, only to apologize and walk away. She had learned to say, "I'm sorry, I thought you might be someone else," in a voice that did not break, and she had learned to keep walking, because stopping would mean giving up, and giving up would mean losing him twice.