A Sandwich in Winter

Chapter 35

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Margaret Hart was running down the alley. She had not planned to run. She had been walking with her friend Ruth toward the bakery district, talking about nothing in particular, about the snow and the price of bread and the shelter volunteer who had called again, when she had glanced down the side street and seen her daughter standing close to a strange man in a black coat, in an alley, with steam rising around them. Something in her, something older than thought, something made of ten years of worry and every mother's fear, had taken over. She had not stopped to think about who the man was, or whether Clara looked afraid — Clara did not look afraid at all, which Margaret did not notice — she had only seen her daughter, and a stranger, and the narrow walls of the alley, and she had run.

"Clara!" Margaret shouted again, her dark purple coat flapping around her, her boots slipping a little on the icy ground. "Come here! Come away from him, right now!"

Clara turned, startled, her face draining of colour. "Mum? What are you — Mum, stop, it's all right, he's —"

But Margaret was already there, already reaching for her daughter's arm, already pulling her back with a strength Clara had not known she had. She pulled Clara behind her, placing her own body between Clara and Elias, as if she could shield her daughter with nothing more than herself and her coat. Her breath came in gasps, and her hands were shaking, and she was speaking quickly, the words tumbling over each other.

"Are you hurt? Did he hurt you? Clara, answer me, are you all right? I saw you from the street, I thought — I thought —"

"Mum, I'm fine!" Clara cried, trying to free her arm, trying to turn back toward Elias. "Mum, please, you're scaring him, you're scaring both of us, he's not — he's a friend, he's —"

Elias had stepped back at once, his hands raised, palms open, in the universal gesture of a man who wants to show he means no harm. His coffee cup had fallen, spilling dark liquid across the snow, and the sandwich bag lay forgotten on the crate. He looked, Clara thought later, like a man who had been expecting this moment for a very long time, and dreading it, and yet was not surprised by it. He looked at Margaret, and then at Clara, and then back at Margaret, and his face went through a series of changes too quick to name: fear, recognition, grief, and something that might have been hope, quickly suppressed.

"I'm sorry," Elias said, his voice hoarse. "I didn't mean — I wasn't — Clara, I'm sorry, I should go."

"No," Clara said, but Margaret was still holding her arm, still breathing hard, still looking at Elias as if he were a danger she had to assess. And then, as Elias turned to go, as he raised his hand to pull his coat tighter around him, his sleeve slipped back.

It was a small thing. A sleeve slipping back in winter, revealing a wrist. Nothing more. But Margaret saw it, and she stopped breathing.

On Elias's left wrist, pale against his cold-reddened skin, was a small, crescent-shaped scar.

Margaret's hand, which had been gripping Clara's arm, went slack. Her mouth opened, but no sound came out at first. The alley, which a moment before had been full of shouting and footsteps and the hiss of steam, went suddenly, impossibly quiet. Snow fell, soft and steady, landing on Margaret's purple coat, on Clara's blonde hair, on Elias's black coat, and none of them moved.

"That scar," Margaret whispered, and her voice was not the voice of a woman shouting in panic. It was the voice of a woman speaking to a ghost. "That scar. Where did you get that scar?"

Elias froze. He looked down at his own wrist, as if he had forgotten the scar was there, as if he had lived with it for so long that it had become part of him, like a birthmark, like a name. Slowly, very slowly, he pulled his sleeve back down, but it was too late. Margaret had seen it, and Clara, turning to look, had seen her mother's face, and something in that face told her, before any words did, that this was not an ordinary moment.

"Answer me," Margaret said, and now her voice was shaking, not with anger, but with something far more fragile. "Please. Where did you get that scar?"

Elias opened his mouth, and closed it again. He looked at Clara, and Clara looked at him, and in that look, years collapsed. She saw, suddenly and with terrible clarity, the boy who had thrown himself in front of a bicycle on a snowy hill when she was four years old, and the young man who had drawn houses in the margins of his schoolbooks, and the man who had shaded a brick wall in charcoal in exactly the same way. She saw the hands she had remembered, older now, thinner, scarred, but still his hands. She saw the brow, furrowed in concentration, and the mouth, set in a line she had seen in a photograph propped against a sugar bowl.

"I got it when I was nine," Elias said at last, his voice barely above a whisper, and every word seemed to cost him something. "There was a hill. And a bicycle. And my little sister was in the way."

Clara made a sound, small and broken, like a sob caught halfway. "No," she said. "No, that can't —"

Margaret took a step forward, her hand reaching out, trembling so violently that Clara could see it from where she stood. She did not touch him yet. She held her hand in the air between them, as if she were afraid that if she touched him, he might disappear, as if he were made of snow and might melt.

News in the same category

A Sandwich in Winter

45 Part