A Sandwich in Winter

Chapter 33

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Elias looked down at his own hands, which were red with cold and stained with charcoal, and he curled his fingers slowly into his palms. His left wrist, where his coat sleeve had ridden up, showed a pale crescent against his skin. Clara saw it, and she did not know why her throat tightened, only that it did. She had seen that scar before, too, in a different life, when she was four years old and a bicycle had come hurtling down a snowy hill toward her, and a boy had thrown himself in front of her and taken the fall against an iron fence. She remembered the blood, and the crying, and her mother holding them both, and her brother saying, through tears, that it was all right, that scars were just proof you had been brave. But that memory was so old, and so tangled up with childhood, that she could not hold it steady. It slipped away from her even as she reached for it, like snow melting on a warm hand.

"I should get back," she said, standing up too quickly. Her voice sounded strange to her own ears. "The bakery — I left the ovens."

Elias nodded, but he did not unfold the newspaper again until she had gone inside. Clara stood behind the bakery counter for a long time, her hands in the flour, her mind racing. She told herself she was being foolish. Chicago was full of men who could draw. Chicago was full of men with scars. The fact that this man drew the way her brother had drawn, and had a scar on his left wrist, and liked to talk about buildings as if they were people, did not mean he was her brother. It could not mean that. And yet, when she thought about the way he had looked at her that first day, when she had handed him a sandwich and he had looked stunned, as if kindness were a language he had forgotten how to speak, she felt a pull she could not explain.

That evening, Clara went home late. Margaret was at the kitchen table, and the photograph was still propped against the sugar bowl. Clara stopped in the doorway. She had not seen that photograph out in the open for years. Her mother usually kept it tucked away, as if looking at it too often might wear it out.

"Why is that out?" Clara asked, trying to keep her voice light.

Margaret looked up, and for a moment she looked almost guilty. "I found it in my wallet this morning," she said. "I went to the shelter. The volunteer didn't recognize him, but I thought — I don't know what I thought. I just wanted to look at him for a while."

Clara sat down opposite her mother and looked at the photograph, really looked at it, for the first time in a long time. Elias at eighteen, with a pencil behind his ear, his brow furrowed in concentration, his hands resting on the table. She studied those hands. They were young, unscarred except for the faint crescent on the left wrist, which the camera had caught almost by accident, a pale mark against his skin. Her heart began to beat very fast.

"Mum," she said slowly, "do you remember how Elias used to draw? The shading, the little compass rose in the corner of everything?"

Margaret's eyes filled with tears, but she smiled. "He drew it on everything. His homework, his notebooks, the backs of envelopes. Your father used to pretend to be annoyed, but he kept every one of them."

Clara opened her mouth to tell her mother about the man in the alley, about the newspaper and the charcoal and the shading, but the words stuck. What if she was wrong? What if she raised her mother's hopes only to have them broken again? Margaret had already endured ten years of false hopes, of men who looked a little like Elias from behind, of phone calls that led nowhere. Clara could not bear to be the person who gave her another one. And besides, she told herself, she had no proof. Only a feeling, and a drawing she had not even kept, and a scar she had glimpsed for a second in the snow.

So she said only, "I miss him," which was true, and Margaret reached across the table and took her hand, which was also true, and they sat together in the warm kitchen while the snow fell outside and the photograph watched them from its place by the sugar bowl.

The next day, Clara went to the alley earlier than usual. Elias was not there at first, and her stomach tightened with a fear she did not want to name. She set the sandwich down on the crate, wrapped in paper, and waited, stamping her feet against the cold, watching her breath rise in small clouds. After twenty minutes, he came around the corner, walking slowly, his coat pulled tight, his hands in his pockets. He looked tired, and a little thinner than he had the week before, but when he saw her, something in his face softened.

"You waited," he said.

"I always wait," Clara said. "It's cold. Eat before it gets cold."

He sat down and unwrapped the sandwich, and as he did, Clara noticed the folded newspaper tucked under his arm. He set it down beside him, on top of the crate, and then, as if he had changed his mind about hiding it, he left it there. They talked about ordinary things: the snow, the bakery's new oven, a dog someone had seen chasing its own tail in the park. Elias laughed once, a real laugh, short and surprised, as if he had forgotten he could do that, and Clara laughed too, and for a few minutes the alley did not feel like an alley at all. It felt like a room, warm despite the cold, with steam rising from the grate like breath.

News in the same category

A Sandwich in Winter

45 Part