She counted forty-four.
Seven sacks of oats were missing.
Delia stood in the feed shed with the dust in her throat and the numbers in her head, and she felt the cold settle somewhere lower than her skin. Fourteen bales of hay. Seven sacks of oats. That was not a mouse's work, and it was not a miscount, because she had counted twice, and Fern had chalked the tens, and the arithmetic was plain as a fence post. But it was also not proof of anything, not yet. A ranch was a living place, and living places leaked: a bale fed to a sick calf in the night, a sack split and swept up, a load taken to the lower pasture she had not been told about. There were explanations, and a fair woman owed a place its explanations before she owed it her suspicions.
She found Jude Slade at the wagon, tightening a rope.
"Mr. Slade," she said, "a question about the hay. Mr. Ash told me seven loads went into the shed in September, twenty bales to the load — one hundred and forty bales. I've counted one hundred and six. The cattle eat about a bale a day, and we've had three weeks. That leaves fourteen I can't account for. Have we fed extra somewhere I haven't seen?"
He did not look up at once. He finished the knot, tugged it twice, and then he looked at her, and his face was the face of a man being asked a question he had already answered somewhere else.
"Could be the lower pasture," he said. "We took a load down there in the cold snap, before you came. Fourteen bales sounds about right for that."
"And the oats?" Delia asked. "Fifty-eight sacks on the receipt, seven fed by your measure, forty-four on the bins. Seven short there too."
"The lower pasture again," he said, too quickly, and then, as if hearing himself, he slowed. "Horses down there need oats as well as hay, Mrs. Harlow. You can't feed one without the other. Ask Mr. Ash. He'll tell you the same."
Delia nodded, as if satisfied, and wrote nothing in front of him. She thanked him and walked back to the house with Fern, and all the way across the yard she kept her face quiet, the way she had learned to keep it when a pot was about to boil and showing alarm would only make it boil faster.
But quiet was not the same as finished. Delia had never been a woman who let a question sit unasked when her feet could go and look. After the midday meal was served and the hands had gone back to the cattle, she told Fern to stay with Kit and the chickens, put on her shawl, and walked down to the lower pasture herself.
It was a longer walk than it looked from the house, down a slope of dry grass to the narrow strip of ground along the creek where the land flattened and the willows grew thick. The fence there was a tired thing, its posts leaning and two rails gone altogether, and the grass inside it stood unbitten and tall, gone to seed. There was no trough. There was no shelter. There was no sign that horses had been fed there at all: no trampled circle where animals might have stood to eat, no scattered oats in the dirt, no fresh droppings, no wagon ruts leading down the slope except one old pair, grassed over, from some summer long past. A place where horses had been fed through a cold snap would have shown it. This place showed nothing but neglect and the creek running cold and clear beside it.
Delia stood there a long time, her shawl pulled close, looking at the empty pasture the way she had looked at the numbers in the feed shed: not angry, not yet, but attentive. A cook learned early that the difference between a good kitchen and a bad one was not the size of the fire but whether anyone was paying attention. Someone had not been paying attention here, or someone had been paying attention to something else entirely. She did not know which. She walked the fence line once, to be thorough, and found nothing more, and then she walked back up the hill, slowly, because her knees were not young anymore and because thinking was easier when her feet were moving.