He questioned them separately, and Jonah respected him for it even as it chafed. First Nalzhe, away from the column: how many in the band, where they had come from, where they were going, whether any man among them carried a rifle. Nalzhe answered plainly, and when Weller asked whether they meant harm to any settler, Nalzhe said, "We mean to drink. That is all we mean." Weller wrote it down.
Then Jonah, apart, under the thin shade of a dead palo verde: how long he had been with the band, what he knew of the water, whether he had seen Crowe's men fire. Jonah told the truth as far as it went — warning shots fired over the band days earlier, Booker's riders shadowing them, the dry waterhole where he had stood unarmed between Booker and the band and talked the man down. He did not tell Weller about the canyon, or the pool. A secret told to the Army became a report, and a report became an order, and Jonah had quit the Army thirteen years ago precisely because he did not trust orders to be kind. He told Weller only that the band was peaceful, that they were dying of thirst, and that Crowe meant to stop them reaching water.
Do you believe Mr. Crowe will fire on unarmed people, Mr. Reed? Weller asked.
Jonah thought of Booker's grin at the waterhole, and the way the man's hand had rested on his rifle. "I believe Mr. Crowe will warn them," Jonah said carefully. "I believe his foreman will do more than warn them, if he is given the chance."
Weller wrote that down too.
Then Weller rode to Crowe's men. He did not ride to the canyon — not yet. He rode back along the trail to where Booker's riders had been seen shadowing the column, found two of them watering their horses at a dry tank, and questioned them where they stood, with Sergeant O'Rourke beside him. The men told their story readily: the Apaches were trespassing, Crowe was defending his property, the shots had been warnings, nothing more, and Reed was a drifter with no authority leading savages toward a rancher's water. Weller listened without interrupting. He asked about the barricade at the canyon mouth — he had heard of it from a rider out of Red Wash — and the men grew evasive, and looked at each other, and said they knew nothing of any barricade, only that Mr. Crowe was "securing his interests."
O'Rourke waited until they were riding back toward the band before he spoke. He was forty-one, Irish, gruff, with twenty years of frontier service in his face, and the sergeant's gift of saying in few words what an officer needed to hear and did not want to.
Sir, O'Rourke said, "with respect, this is not our fight — until it is."
Meaning? Weller asked.
Meaning Crowe's men are lying about the barricade, or they are ignorant, and neither is comforting. Meaning that band is walking toward a wall of rock with children in their arms, and if Crowe has closed the only gap in that wall, there will be a fight, and it will be our fight, because we will be the only law within sixty miles, and the report we write afterward will not bring anyone back to life. O'Rourke spat dust. "Meaning, sir, that a young officer does not want his first independent command to end with dead children in a canyon mouth and his name on the paper explaining why he stayed on the trail asking questions."
Weller was quiet for a long stretch of trail. The heat beat down. The patrol rode in silence behind him. Jonah, watching from the band's column, could not hear what was said, but he could see the set of the young lieutenant's shoulders change, the way a man's shoulders change when a decision settles into them.
When Weller rode back to Nalzhe and Jonah, his face was set and his voice formal, but underneath the formality there was a troubled fairness, a man trying to be just in a place where justice had very little water to work with.
Mr. Reed, Chief Nalzhe, Weller said, "I am noncommittal as to the rights in this dispute. I have heard three accounts, and they do not agree. But I am troubled by what I have heard about a blockade at the canyon ahead, and I am troubled by the condition of your people." He looked at Chulo, limp and feverish in Biyé's arms, and at the empty gourds swinging at the women's hips. "I will ride to the canyon myself, with my patrol, to see the state of things with my own eyes. I will speak to Mr. Crowe there. No one is to fire on anyone while I am on the road. Do you understand me?"
We understand, Nalzhe said.
And you, Mr. Reed — Weller held Jonah's gaze. "If there is water ahead, and if Mr. Crowe has closed it to people who are dying, I will want to know it. Not from rumor. From the ground itself. I will see it."
Jonah nodded. He did not promise more than that. He could not, without breaking faith with the secret he had carried for twelve years, and he would not break faith with it to a man in blue, however fair, until the band had drunk.
Weller mounted, and the patrol formed up, and they rode west, ahead of the band, toward the red cliffs, leaving dust hanging behind them. Jonah watched them go and felt a complicated relief: law had entered the story, and law was not a friend, but it was not, either, an enemy with a rifle on a rock. It was a third thing, uncertain, and uncertain was better than certain harm.