We walk on, Nalzhe said quietly to Jonah. "Behind the soldiers, but not with them. Let the lieutenant see Crowe's wall before he sees our faces. Let him judge the wall first."
They reached the canyon mouth on the twelfth day, in the late afternoon, when the sun had gone behind the cliffs and the valley lay in a long, cool shadow that made the thirst feel, for a moment, almost bearable.
Jonah knew the place before he saw it, the way a man knows a room he once slept in. The rockfall. The stand of dead mesquite, gray branches reaching up like hands. The gap between the boulders, barely wide enough for two horses abreast, stone rising sheer on either side. And across the gap, where there had once been only shadow and fallen stone, a barricade: dead brush piled high, stones rolled into the spaces between, a tangle of mesquite limbs and boulders rising to a man's chest and higher, closing the throat of the canyon as thoroughly as a fist closing around a windpipe.
On the rocks above the gap, rifles caught the last light.
Booker stood on the highest rock, his rifle in his hands, his face lit from below by the reflected heat of the stone. Beside him two of Crowe's riders crouched with rifles across their knees. Below, at the foot of the barricade, Crowe himself stood with his arms folded, broad and red-faced, flanked by three more men. Pruitt's wagon was drawn up a little way off, the barrel gleaming, Pruitt sitting on the wagon seat with his hat tipped back, watching like a man at a fair.
That's far enough! Booker shouted. His voice bounced off the rock and came back doubled. "This canyon is closed! Private water! Turn around and walk back the way you came!"
Nalzhe stepped forward, alone, into the open ground between the band and the barricade. He carried no weapon. His hands hung empty at his sides. His gray-streaked braids lay still against his shoulders. He stopped where his voice would carry without shouting, and spoke in English, slowly, so every man on the rocks could hear him.
We are not here to take your water, Nalzhe said. "We are here to drink. Our children are dying. There is water beyond this rock. We ask to pass. We will drink, and we will go. We will not stay. We will not dam. We will share."
Crowe answered from below the barricade, his voice rough. "There is no water here for you. This is my claim. I found it. I closed it. You turn back, Chief, and no one gets hurt."
Jonah stepped up beside Nalzhe. He kept his hands away from his rifle and his voice low and even, the way he had kept it at the dry waterhole when he stood unarmed between Booker and the band.
Mr. Crowe, Jonah said, "you know these people are not raiders. You know they have fired no shot at you. You know that boy — " He gestured, without turning, toward Chulo, limp in Biyé's arms behind him. "You know that boy will not live another day without water. Let them through the gap. Let them drink. You can stand here and watch every one of them drink, and count them out again when they are done. No one is asking you to give up your ranch."
I am asking you to turn back, Crowe said. His face was flushed, grief curdled into hardness. "I warned you, Reed. I warned you at Red Wash. Lead them anywhere but my well, and you answer to me. Well, here is your answer."
For a long moment nothing moved. The wind stirred the dead mesquite and then died. The band stood in the shadow of the cliffs, the riders stood on the rocks above, and the barricade stood between them. Jonah could smell the water, faintly, a green, living smell of cottonwood and wet stone, coming through the gap on the evening air. It lay beyond, unreachable, forty feet of clear, shaded pool that none of them could touch.
Then Booker fired.
It was not a shot at a person. Jonah saw that even as the sound cracked off the rock. Booker's rifle kicked, and the bullet struck low, into the flank of one of the band's pack horses — a sturdy, dun-colored animal that had carried the band's bundles for days, standing patiently at the edge of the column with its head down. The horse screamed, a sound Jonah had heard only twice before and never wanted to hear again, and went down on its forelegs, then struggled up, limping, blood darkening its dun coat in a spreading stain. It did not fall again. It stood, trembling, head turned toward the wound, while Bayan and Haska ran to it, caught its bridle, and spoke to it in low, urgent voices. Nah-tee was already moving, medicine bundle in her hands, toward the animal.
Hold! Nalzhe shouted. His voice cut through the ringing in Jonah's ears like an axe. "Hold! No one moves! No one shoots!"
Dos-teh had his hand on his knife. Nadene had her sling half-raised. Half the hunters had reached for whatever weapons they carried — knives, a sling, a single old rifle — and Nalzhe's order stopped them where they stood, shaking with a fury Jonah could feel in his own chest like a second heartbeat.
No retaliation, Nalzhe said, and he turned and faced his own people, so Crowe's men could see his back, undefended, and the band could see his face. "No retaliation. If we shoot, they shoot. If they shoot, children die. We did not walk three days across a desert to die in the shadow of water. We will not give them the fight they want. No one fires. No one throws. We camp here, where they can see us, and we wait, and we live until morning."