Banker Called a Black Forensic Accountant “Filthy” — Then Her Court Order Froze Every Account

Chapter 13

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Daphne's lawyer, when his turn came, told the story he had decided to tell. He said that his client had been the victim of a trap, that the test account had been planted by people who wanted to embarrass her, that the case had grown out of a personal insult rather than a crime, and that a woman who had been insulted in a lobby had used the power of the court to punish the woman who had insulted her. He said that Daphne Lark had treated all customers the same, and that the prosecution had taken ordinary banking procedures and dressed them up as a conspiracy, and that the jury should not be fooled by a stack of paper into believing that a busy branch manager and a senior advisor and an operations supervisor had set out to steal from the dead. He called a witness, a former colleague, who said that Daphne had always been professional, and he called another, who said that the branch had been under pressure to meet targets, as if pressure were an explanation. He did not call anyone who could explain the complaint reclassifications, or the account status change, or the Caldwell transfers, or the second ledger, because there was no one who could explain those things, and he knew it, and the jury, Kendra thought, knew it too, because they watched him the way people watch a man building a house out of cards, waiting to see which card would be the one that brought it down.

Kendra testified on the fourth day. She walked to the stand, and she was sworn in, and she sat down, and she placed her hands on the rail, and she answered Ada's questions the way she had answered them in preparation, quietly and precisely, with the documents in front of her. She explained the quiet accounts method, and the returned-mail list, and the backdated powers of attorney, and the false bills of sale, and the consulting fees, and the total of about seven point four million dollars, and she explained it the way she had explained it to the families, in plain language, without jargon, without anger, without asking the jury to feel anything except attention. Then the defense lawyer cross-examined her, and he asked her about the test account, and about whether she had been insulted in the lobby, and about whether she had felt anger, and about whether the case had begun with a personal grievance. Kendra answered that she had been kept waiting, and that she had been spoken to dismissively, and that she had not enjoyed it, and that none of that was the reason for the case, because the case had begun months before she ever entered the branch, with Paula Ansley's letter and the probate records and the complaint audit trail, and because the Beale account had been placed in the ordinary course of business, and because Daphne Lark had not been instructed to do anything, and had done, on her own, exactly what she had done to dozens of accounts before it. The defense lawyer asked her whether she was certain. Kendra said that she was certain about what the documents showed, and that she distinguished, always, between what she suspected and what she could prove, and that what she could prove was in the file, and that the file was before the court. The lawyer had no further questions. He sat down, and Kendra was excused, and she walked back to the gallery, and Paula Ansley reached over and touched her hand, briefly, and Kendra touched hers back, and that was all, because a courtroom is not a place for more than that, and because more than that was not needed.

The closing arguments took a full day. Ada spoke first, and she did not speak about vengeance, and she did not speak about the insult in the lobby, except to say that the insult was not the crime, and that the jury should not confuse the two, because the crime was the theft, and the theft had been going on for five years, and the insult was only the moment when the theft had been seen. She spoke about the families, and about the accounts, and about the paper, and she ended by asking the jury to follow the paper where it led, and to hold each defendant responsible for the part he or she had played. The defense lawyers spoke after her, each in turn, and they spoke about reasonable doubt, and about the test account, and about the pressure of targets, and about the difference between a mistake and a crime, and they spoke well, because they were good lawyers, and because good lawyers can make even a weak case sound like a question worth asking. But the documents were still on the table, and the jury had seen them, and the jury had heard Devon Frye and Ruth Hammond and the compliance officers and Kendra, and the jury had heard the lobby recording, and when the judge gave them their instructions and sent them out, they filed out of the courtroom in a line, twelve people who had spent two weeks listening to a story about a bank and a shell company and a list of quiet accounts, and who now had to decide what that story meant.

News in the same category

Banker Called a Black Forensic Accountant “Filthy” — Then Her Court Order Froze Every Account

45 Part