Banker Called a Black Forensic Accountant “Filthy” — Then Her Court Order Froze Every Account

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

As the audit widened, the picture grew larger and uglier. The investigators pulled five years of records, not just from the downtown branch but from five other branches in the region, and they found the same pattern, smaller in some places, larger in others, always with the same shell company at the center, always with the same phrases on the transfer memos. The total, when Kendra added it up and checked it twice, was about seven point four million dollars, taken from more than sixty accounts, over five years. The number was not the largest fraud Kendra had ever documented, but it was, in its way, the most deliberate, because every account belonged to someone who was dead or incapacitated or caring for someone who was, and because the people who took the money had chosen their victims precisely for their inability to notice or to fight back. Kendra also found the two compliance officers who had, at different times, noticed odd withdrawals and accepted Warren's explanations without contacting the families. One of them had written, in a memo, that a customer who had called to complain was confused and emotional. The other had described Paula Ansley as aggressive. Kendra pulled the call recordings, because the bank recorded its customer service lines, and she listened to Paula's call, and what she heard was not aggression. It was a woman who was frightened and exhausted, trying to explain that her father could not have used a computer, being interrupted nine times by a representative who did not want to hear it. Kendra put the recording in the file, with a note, because the difference between what was written about Paula and what Paula had actually said was, in itself, part of the story, and because juries understand that difference when they hear it.

Warren Fitch began to cooperate in the third week. He did not do it out of remorse, at least not at first. He did it because his lawyer showed him the second ledger and the Caldwell statements and the returned-mail list with his handwriting on it, and because the lawyer told him, plainly, that the case against him did not depend on anyone's memory, and that the longer he waited, the less there would be to trade. Warren told the investigators about the first theft, which had happened almost by accident, five years earlier, when an account belonging to a man who had died without close family had sat untouched for months, and Warren had realized, with a clarity that he later described as both thrilling and sickening, that no one was going to ask about it. He had moved a small amount, labeled as a fee, and nothing had happened. No one had called. No letter had bounced back with a question attached. He had moved a larger amount, and again nothing had happened, and from there the method had grown, first with Oscar's help, then with Daphne's, until it was a routine, and routines, Warren said, are the most dangerous things in the world, because once something is a routine you stop thinking about whether it is right, and you start thinking only about whether it is done correctly. He described the quiet accounts method in detail, and he named the accounts, and he confirmed the role of the cousin's firm, and he said, at the end of a long afternoon, that he had known for a long time that it would end, and that he had simply hoped it would end after he retired. Kendra wrote it all down, and she did not thank him, and she did not condemn him, because neither response was her job. Her job was the record.

Daphne Lark did not cooperate. She hired a lawyer, and she denied everything that could be denied, and she gave a statement in which she said that she had not acted out of prejudice, that she had treated all customers the same, and that the test account had been a trap, set by people who wanted to embarrass her, and that the case against her had grown out of an insult rather than a crime. Kendra read the statement carefully, and she noted what it did not say. It did not explain the complaint reclassifications. It did not explain the account status change on the Beale account. It did not explain the Caldwell transfers. It did not explain why the customers she had made wait, and whose papers she had doubted, were so often the same kind of customer, when the bank's own lobby logs showed the pattern. Kendra did not argue with the statement. She added it to the file, alongside Devon's account and the lobby recording and the system logs, and she let the documents answer it, because documents, unlike people, do not get tired and do not change their stories. She also met, one by one, with the families, in their homes and in her office and once, at Paula's request, in the kitchen where Paula had first opened the statement that did not add up, and she told them what had been found, and what had not yet been found, and what would happen next, and she told them the truth about the timeline, which was that getting money back would take months, and that some of the money had been spent, and that the bank would have to be made to pay, and that making a bank pay is a process, not a moment. The families listened, and they asked questions, and some of them cried, and some of them were angry, and some of them were simply quiet, the way people are quiet when they have been carrying something heavy for a long time and someone has finally offered to help carry it.

News in the same category

Banker Called a Black Forensic Accountant “Filthy” — Then Her Court Order Froze Every Account

45 Part