I had not touched her. That was the one clear fact I could hold on to in the dark. I had not touched her. I had come up the stairs because I heard a noise. I had stopped several feet away from her. I had raised my hands and asked her what was wrong. And then Daniel had come home early, and the story had already been written before I could say a word.
Margaret would have known what to do. She had a way of going very still when other people were shouting, and then saying one plain sentence that made the shouting seem foolish. I missed her most on nights like that, in the small, practical way: I wanted to turn over and say, "Margaret, what do I do now?" She had been gone five years. Her chair at the head of the table stood empty, and I still set it straight every morning. The white roses she loved were gone from the garden now, but I could see the bare stems from my bedroom window, and I knew where they would come back in the spring.
I must have dozed at last, because I woke to grey light coming through the curtains and the sound of rain starting against the glass. It was just after six. The house was quiet. Daniel and Mia had taken the children home late the night before, after Mia had stopped crying long enough to say she did not want to stay in this house another minute, and Daniel had looked at me as if I were a stranger who had wandered in off the street.
I got up, put on my dressing gown, and went downstairs. I made tea I did not drink. I stood at the kitchen window and watched the rain darken the path to the gate. And then, quite calmly, as if someone else had decided it for me, I thought of the camera.
I had put it there six months earlier, after Mrs. Alvarez next door had her back door forced while she was at her daughter's. I had bought a small black camera and fixed it high on the hallway wall, near the smoke detector, where it would see the stairs and the landing and the window at the end of the hall. It was not a secret. I had told Daniel and Claire about it at the time. It recorded when it sensed movement, and saved everything to a small recorder box in my study, and to an app on my phone. A red light blinked when it was recording.
My hands were shaking when I went into the study. I am seventy years old, and I have never been a brave man in the way soldiers are brave, only in the ordinary way, when a man pays his bills and keeps his house standing and does not run away from a difficult conversation. But that morning my hands shook, and I had to sit down at the desk and breathe for a minute before I could touch the recorder.
The study was cold. The photo album from our trip to Maine sat on the shelf above the desk, its cover faded by the sun. I did not open it. I looked at the recorder box instead, a plain black box with a single blinking light, tucked beside the computer monitor.
I opened the app on my phone first. It was simpler than the computer, and I did not want to make a mistake. The app showed a list of clips, each marked with a date and a time. I scrolled back to yesterday afternoon. There it was: 4:47 p.m. Motion detected, hallway. The length was a little over six minutes.
I stared at the small thumbnail for a long time. A still image of my own hallway, empty. The window at the end, with the late afternoon light coming through it. The top of the stairs. Nothing in it that should have frightened anyone.
I pressed play.
At first, there was nothing. The hallway was empty, the way it is for most of the day. Then Mia came into frame from the direction of the spare room. She was alone. She was wearing the green satin blouse she had worn to lunch, the one with the small buttons down the front. Her hair was neat. Her face was calm. She walked to the window at the end of the landing and stood there for a moment, looking out at the garden.