I sat on the edge of the bed with the first letter in my hands, and I did not open it right away. I turned it over and over, feeling the weight of the paper, the slight roughness where her pen had pressed hard. I thought about the woman who had written it, sitting in her chair by the window, probably in the afternoon light, probably tired, probably in pain, and choosing her words with care because she knew they mattered.
At last I opened it.
She began the way she always began a letter to me, even when I was in the next room. My dearest Thomas. She wrote that some things were easier to say on paper, where she could get them right, that she loved our life together and was proud of the children we had raised. And then, gently, she wrote what she had seen.
She had seen Mia at my desk, she wrote, one afternoon when I was out in the garden and Daniel was at work. Mia had been standing there with her phone in her hand, and when Margaret came into the room, Mia had put the phone away too quickly and said she was only looking for a pen. Margaret had not said anything at the time. She had gone back to the kitchen and made tea, and she had told herself she was imagining things, that grief and illness made a person suspicious. But later, when she went to straighten the papers on my desk, she saw that they had been moved. Not much. Just enough. A stack of bills that had been square was now crooked. A folder I kept for the house papers was open when I always left it closed.
She wrote that she had watched Mia more carefully after that, not because she wanted to find something wrong, but because she could not stop herself. She saw Mia ask me, more than once, where the house deed was kept. She heard her ask about the will, casually, as if it were a normal thing to ask about over dinner, whether I had made one, whether it was up to date, whether I had thought about what would happen to the house. She heard her ask about insurance, about what policies I had, about how much they were worth. Margaret wrote that Mia always smiled when she asked, always made it sound like she was only concerned, only trying to help, and that was what troubled her most. It was not the questions themselves. It was the way they never stopped.
I put the letter down on the bed and sat very still. My hands were shaking. I could see that afternoon in my mind, the light coming through the living-room window, Mia standing at my desk with her phone in her hand. I had not been there. Margaret had. She had seen it and carried it alone, because she did not want to make trouble in the family, because she loved Mia, because she hoped she was wrong.
I picked up the second letter. It was dated in June, and the handwriting was a little less steady. She wrote that she was weaker now and spent most afternoons resting with the door open so she could hear the house, and that hearing Ethan and Lily when they visited kept her going on the hard days.
And then she wrote about the money. She had lent Mia money, she said, twice, from her own small savings, the money she kept for herself, for birthdays and small kindnesses. The first time Mia had asked for help with a bill and promised to pay it back the next week. The second time she had asked for more and said she would tell Daniel, but she had not. Margaret had found out by accident, when Daniel mentioned that money was tight and Mia had said nothing about the loan. Margaret had not confronted her. She had written that she did not want to embarrass Mia, that she understood what it was like to be short and ashamed, but that it worried her. A person who borrowed in secret, she wrote, was a person who was already keeping something from the people who loved her.