"We'll show Daniel soon," I said.
Claire nodded. "Soon," she said. "Together."
Outside, the light went out of the garden, and the house settled around us, quiet and waiting, as it had been all day.
Chapter 8: The Confrontation
I did not sleep the night before I called him. I lay awake listening to the house settle around me in the autumn cold, and I thought about Margaret. She had never liked a raised voice in this house. Even when Daniel was a boy and came home late with a lie half-formed on his lips, she would wait until the shouting had left him, and then she would speak quietly, because she believed a man could only hear the truth when he was not defending himself against it.
I wanted Daniel to hear the truth. I did not want him to feel cornered by it.
In the morning I stood at the kitchen window watching the white roses, Margaret's favourites, pale now and bruised by frost. I thought about the camera I had put up six months earlier, after Mrs. Alden's house two doors down was broken into. I had not put it up to catch anyone in my own family. I had put it up because I was seventy and lived alone and wanted to feel safe in my own hallway. I had not imagined it would one day hold the only proof that I had not done what my own son believed I had done.
I rang Daniel at nine o'clock. Mia answered first, and for a moment my heart went tight, but then Daniel came to the phone, his voice still thick with sleep.
"Dad? Is everything all right?"
"Everything is all right," I said. "I would like you to come over this evening, Daniel. Just you. After the children are in bed. There is something I need to show you, and I would rather show it to you here, quietly, than have it come out any other way."
"Is it about Mia?" he asked.
"It is about that night in the hallway," I said. "That is all I will say on the phone. Come at seven. I will make tea."
He said he would come. I spent the day doing ordinary things, because ordinary things were the only way I knew to keep my hands from shaking. I swept the leaves from the front step. I checked, twice, that the recording was still there on the laptop and that it would play.
I had watched the footage myself more times than I could count. I knew every second of it by heart, and still, each time, something in me flinched. Not at what Mia did. What flinched in me was the sight of my son's hand, and the sound it made, and the look on my own face in the seconds after, an old man's face, bewildered and hurt, staring at the boy he had raised.
After she hung up, I took the USB stick from my desk drawer, the small silver one I had copied the recording onto, and left it in an envelope on the corner of the desk. I did not know if Daniel would want it. I only knew I wanted him to have the choice.
At seven o'clock precisely, Daniel knocked on the front door. I opened it and saw him standing there in his work jacket, his hands in his pockets, his face tired from a long day at the warehouse. He looked older than forty-two in the porch light. He looked like a man who had not been sleeping well.
"Come in," I said. "It is cold out there."
He stepped inside and stamped the leaves from his shoes, the way Margaret had taught him to do when he was small, and I felt a sudden ache at how much of his mother was still in him.
"I made tea," I said. "In the study. We can sit there. It is warmer."
He followed me down the hallway without speaking. As we passed the spot where it had happened, I saw his eyes flick towards the faint scuff on the wall and then away again. The camera was still there, small and black, tucked up near the smoke detector. He glanced up at it too, and then he looked at me.
"Dad—"
"Not yet," I said gently. "Sit down first. Tea first."
The study was the warmest room in the house in autumn, with the lamp on and the curtains drawn. Margaret's photograph stood on the desk, the one from Maine, her hair lifted by the wind off the water, laughing at something I had said just out of frame. I had put the laptop on the desk beside it, closed, waiting.