I left the pantry and went back to the sitting room. I sat in my armchair by the fire and tried to read, but I stared at the same page for ten minutes without taking in a single word. I put the book down again. I was ashamed that my son had hit me, and ashamed that I had let him, and ashamed that part of me was more afraid of losing him than I was angry at what he had done. A father is supposed to stand up and say, you will not do that in my house. I had not done that.
It was past midnight when I finally gave up on the idea of sleep and went to my study. I told myself I was only going to sit in there for a while, among my books and my papers, where the room still smelled faintly of Margaret's lavender, because she used to come in here to bring me tea when I was working late. I told myself I was not going to touch the camera.
But I already knew I was lying to myself.
The recorder box sat on the shelf above my desk, a small black thing with a single green light, humming very softly. Beside it was my phone, where I had left it charging. I picked the phone up. My hand was shaking. I opened the camera app, the one the installer had shown me how to use six months ago, and the screen filled with a small, grainy picture of my hallway, empty now, the stairs going up, the front door closed.
I sat down at my desk. The house was silent around me. The hallway on the screen was silent too, and still, and waiting.
At the bottom of the screen there was a list of recordings, each one marked with a time. I could see the one from this evening. I did not need to read the time to know which one it was. My thumb hovered over it.
I thought about Daniel's face, and about Claire's hands on my shoulders, and about Ethan on the stairs, and about Margaret's photograph in the sitting room, and about the pencil marks on the pantry wall. I thought about what Daniel had told me not to do, and about what Claire had said — you're choosing the truth — and about how frightened she had been, not of Mia, but of what Daniel might do next.
I was afraid too. I was afraid of what I would see. I was afraid that watching would change everything, that once I had seen it there would be no going back to the way things were before. I was afraid that it would confirm what Claire had said, and that I would have to decide what to do with that knowledge.
But I was more afraid of not knowing. I was more afraid of sitting in this house, night after night, wondering whether my own son believed I was a man who would hurt his wife, and never finding out whether the truth was there, waiting for me, on a small black box on a shelf in my own study.
I did not press play. Not yet. I sat there in the dark, with the phone in my hand and the recording waiting on the screen, my finger hovering over it, and I stared at that small, still picture of my hallway, and I knew, with a certainty that settled over me like cold, that whatever I did next, nothing in this house would ever be quite the same again.
Chapter 3: The File They Tried to Erase
I did not sleep that night. I lay in the dark listening to the house settle around me, and I kept seeing Daniel's hand. Not the slap itself, exactly. The moment just before it, when his face changed. When he stopped being my son and became a husband defending his wife, and I became, in his eyes, something else entirely.
My cheek still stung. Daniel had pulled the slap, I think, at the last instant, the way a man does when he cannot quite believe what his own hand is doing. But the sting was not the worst of it. The worst was the silence afterward. Mia crying into his chest. Ethan frozen at the top of the stairs. Lily with her hand over her mouth. And me, standing in my own hallway with both hands still half-raised, as if I were surrendering to people I had loved for years.