The kitchen table was still covered with paper when Emma Lawson came home from the courthouse, and the late light coming through the window over the sink made the edges of the pages look thin and pale. She had spread her notes out in the order she had taken them, the way she always did when she was trying to hold a complicated set of facts still long enough to see them clearly, and she had left a space in the middle for the copies she had been allowed to make. Her hands were cold from the walk, and she warmed them around a mug before she touched anything again. Ray Calloway was already there, sitting in the chair nearest the back door with his coat still on, as if he had come straight from his truck and had not wanted to waste time taking it off. He had brought a magnifying glass in a worn leather case, and a small notebook with a pencil tucked into its spiral binding, and he set them down beside her papers without saying anything at first, only nodding toward the empty chair across from him.
She thought briefly of Dean Porter questioning her at the courthouse, and set that memory aside to focus on what the papers themselves showed. Emma sat down and pushed the first copy toward him. It was a typed deed, clean and formal, with the parcel number printed in the upper corner and a signature at the bottom that had been made in dark blue ink. The second copy was much like it, and the third, although the names and dates changed, the shape of the documents stayed the same. Beside them she laid her notes from the old hand-written ledger, copied in her own careful hand, with the dates and the parcel numbers and the names of the families who had held the land before the newer papers had been drawn up. She did not explain yet. She let Ray look, because he had known her father and had known the valley when the roads were narrower and the fences were built by the people who lived behind them, and she trusted the way he read a page slowly, line by line, without rushing toward a conclusion.
Ray picked up the magnifying glass and held it over the first signature. He studied it for a long time, then set it down and picked up the second deed and did the same. His face did not change, but his shoulders settled a little lower, as if something he had suspected had become heavier rather than lighter. He pointed to the loop in one letter and then to the same letter on another page, and Emma saw at once what he meant. The signatures were meant to look like they had been written by the same hand on different days, but the pressure was wrong. The lines were too even, too careful, as if someone had traced the shape of a name rather than written it in the ordinary hurry of a working day. On one deed the signature leaned sharply to the right, and on the next it stood almost upright, and the small break between the first and last names appeared in one place and vanished in another. It was not the natural variation of a tired hand. It was the variation of a hand trying to remember how someone else had signed.