He Said "Pretend I'm Your Dad" — The Biker Who Kept a 28-Year Promise, and the Birthday Parcel That Proved Her Father Never Died in That Accident

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

That evening, Emma told Ray Calloway and Helen Lawson exactly what Victor Hale had said. She sat with them at the kitchen table, with her notebook open in front of her, and she read her notes aloud without adding anything or leaving anything out. She told them about the invitation, about the office and the pleasant conversation at the start, about the donation to the library, and about his suggestion that she leave old land matters alone. She told them that he had described the old records as confusing and the land questions as settled, and that he had said digging into the past could cause unnecessary trouble. She told them that she had declined politely, that she had said any donation would need to go through Ruth Delgado and the library board, and that she had kept the meeting short. Ray listened with his arms folded, and Helen listened with her hands around her mug, and neither of them interrupted until she had finished.

When she was done, Ray said that it was good she had written it down at once, and that it was good she had not agreed to anything in private. Helen said that she was proud of the way Emma had handled it, and that a polite refusal was stronger than an angry one, because it left no room for misunderstanding. They talked for a while about what the meeting might mean, but they did not try to decide what Victor Hale had intended beyond what he had actually said. Emma said that she would tell Ruth Delgado about the offer the next day, so that the library would have a proper record of it, and that she would keep her own notes with the rest of her papers. She felt relieved to have told them both the same account, in the same words, so that there would be no confusion later about what had happened in that office.

The following afternoon, Lily Marsh came to the library with her parents, Tom Marsh and Carol Marsh. Emma saw them through the window before they reached the door, Lily walking a little ahead, her coat buttoned up against the wind, and Tom and Carol following close behind, talking quietly to each other. They came inside and stamped the snow from their boots in the entryway, and Lily smiled when she saw Emma, and Tom removed his hat and held it in his hands. Emma greeted them warmly and led them to a table near the history section, where she had already laid out her notes from the old ledger, with the pages marked so that she could find the Marsh entries quickly. She offered them chairs, and she waited until they were settled before she opened the ledger notes.

She showed them the old ledger entries for the Marsh family farm first, reading them aloud slowly so that they could follow along. The entries showed the farm passing within the family, with the boundaries described by the creek and the old oak and the fence line, and the dates matched the years Tom's father and grandfather had worked the land. Emma pointed to each entry with her fingertip, and she explained what the handwriting said and what the parcel numbers meant, and she did not hurry. Lily leaned forward to look, and Carol placed her hand on the table near the papers, and Tom listened with his hat still in his hands, nodding slowly as Emma read. When she finished the first set of entries, she showed them the newer typed deed that listed a different parcel number for part of the same farm, and she explained, plainly, that the number on the typed deed belonged to another piece of land, and that the signature on that deed did not match the signatures in the older records.

Tom asked her what that meant for his family, and Emma answered carefully, without promising more than she could prove. She said that it meant the records did not agree, and that a fair review would need to look at both sets of papers together, side by side, with someone who could check the parcel numbers against the survey maps and the ledger entries. She explained, plainly, what a fair review would need: the original ledger pages, the typed deeds, the survey maps held at the courthouse, and a written record of each mismatch, with dates and parcel numbers noted exactly. She said that Grace Ellison, as county clerk, would be the proper person to receive such a request, and that the review should be open and documented, so that every family affected could see the same papers and ask the same questions. She said that no one should have to accept a private answer to a public question, and that the Marsh family deserved the same fair process as anyone else in the valley.

News in the same category

He Said "Pretend I'm Your Dad" — The Biker Who Kept a 28-Year Promise, and the Birthday Parcel That Proved Her Father Never Died in That Accident

45 Part