HOA BUILT A PIPELINE THROUGH MY RANCH—SO I BOUGHT THE SOURCE AND CUT OFF THEIR WATER SUPPLY

Chapter 29

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"In exchange," Austin said, "Mr. Merritt withdraws the Section Eleven termination notice. The association's water service continues uninterrupted at the contract rate. And the parties enter a ninety-day study period to evaluate a permanent easement arrangement across the south pasture, with an appraisal to follow."

"At the contract rate," Sam said. "State the rate, for the record of this table."

"Eighty-five cents per thousand gallons," Austin said. "The 2009 rate."

"The rate set when Earl Whitaker owned the spring," Sam said. "Before your clients breached Section Seven. Before they cut this man's fence."

"The rate is the rate in the contract," Austin said.

"It is," Sam said. "And the contract is the contract. All of it. Including the termination your clients are asking Joe to tear up in exchange for forgiving fines that were never lawful, repairing a fence they cut, and fifteen thousand dollars."

I had not spoken yet. I find that in a negotiation, as in a pasture, the man who speaks first is usually the man who was sent to find out where the fence is. I already knew where mine was. I poured myself coffee. I let the twelve pages sit.

"Is there a number in here for Number Thirty-One?" I asked at last.

Austin looked at his pages, front and back, the way a man looks for a name on a roster.

"The fifteen thousand is intended as a global—" he said.

"The heifer," I said. "Nineteen months old. Stepped in the edge of a trench your clients dug without a right to dig it. Vet came out twice. She is walking on it now, mostly. There is a bill. There is also a loss if she does not breed right, which we will not know until we know it. Is she in these pages under inconvenience?"

"Mr. Merritt—"

"Is the creek in here?" I asked. "The draw silted where the line crossed it. Ray and I have hauled silt that does not belong to us out of water that does. Is that under inconvenience too? The reseeding. I reseeded that pasture last fall with my own money and my own hours, and your clients scarred nineteen hundred feet of it. Grass is not an inconvenience, young man. Grass is a crop that stands still. A man damages it the way he damages any crop. Slowly, and then all at once, in somebody else's spring."

Margaret had been quiet, which for Margaret is a form of exercise: you could see the effort in it. Now she leaned forward.

"Joe," she said. "This community has been reasonable—"

"Margaret," I said. "You are at my table, so I will be plain and I will be polite, and those are the same thing here. Your board sent violation letters to my ranch about my own gate. Your board fined me for cattle encroaching on an easement that does not exist, in a pasture my grandfather broke in 1952. Your excavator cut three strands of my wire and peeled it back like a can. And your lawyer has driven out from Austin to offer me fifteen thousand dollars, forgiveness for fines I do not owe, and ninety days to study giving you, permanent, the thing you already tried to take. And the water keeps flowing at Earl's 2009 price, as if Earl's contract were a well nobody could ever draw down."

I counted on my fingers, because counting is how I think and because a table understands fingers better than adjectives.

"One. There is no cure in this offer. The road main is still failing. There is no boring contract, no escrow, no lawful main. Two. There is no restoration. A fence is a day of this offer. Nineteen hundred feet of trench, regrading, reseeding — twice, because the first reseeding after a trench always fails in patches, any man who has done it will tell you — is not in these twelve pages. Three. There is no new rate. Eighty-five cents was Earl's price, in Earl's contract, before the breach. Four. There is no apology in it, and I am not a man who needs an apology the way a crop needs rain, but I notice when a table full of paper has no room in it for the word wrong. And five—" I folded the last finger down. "Five. You are asking me to withdraw a lawful notice, given under a contract your side signed, to cure a breach your side chose, because the lawful cure costs one point nine million and the shortcut cost three hundred and ten thousand and somebody at this table does not want to be the person who explains that arithmetic to three hundred and twelve households."

Don made a sound then. Not a word. He was looking at the twelve pages in front of him the way he had looked at Jim Hartley's single sheet in the clubhouse, as if the paper had been in a language he was only now learning he could read.

Austin said, "Mr. Merritt, if you have a counter—"

"I do not have a counter today," I said. "That surprises you. It should not. A counter is for men who have seen a real first offer. What you have brought me is not an offer. It is the shortcut, typed. You have tried to cross my pasture cheaply one more time, only this time the pasture is my kitchen table and the excavator is a leather portfolio."

Sam, beside me, closed his folder, gently, the way a man closes a gate he intends to stay closed.

Austin began, with professional calm, to explain that positions harden, that litigation has costs on all sides, that Day 60 would have consequences his clients were working to avoid, and I let him finish, because a man should be allowed to finish a sentence he will later wish had been shorter.

"Here is my position," I said. "It is the same one I had in my pasture, and it does not harden, because it was never soft. Go home and count again. Count the fence by the strand. Count the trench by the foot. Count the vet bill, and the creek, and the reseeding twice. Count what a lawful main costs and who decided not to build it. Count what water is worth when the man selling it did not breach anything. And count the days. There are twenty-eight. When your count comes out honest, Sam will read it at this table, and I will listen at this table, for as long as the listening takes."

I stood up. In my house, standing ends a meeting the way closing a gate ends a visit to a pasture: without anger, and without ambiguity.

News in the same category

HOA BUILT A PIPELINE THROUGH MY RANCH—SO I BOUGHT THE SOURCE AND CUT OFF THEIR WATER SUPPLY

45 Part