HOA BUILT A PIPELINE THROUGH MY RANCH—SO I BOUGHT THE SOURCE AND CUT OFF THEIR WATER SUPPLY

Chapter 37

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

It did not happen sudden. It just finished happening where people could see it.

The recall petition had two hundred and four signatures on it when Denise Alvarado brought me a copy, and she was careful to tell me that a copy was all it was.

"I'm not asking you to do anything with it," she said, standing in my yard with her nurse's shoes still on and a folder held against her side like a chart. "You have done your part by standing still. I just thought the man whose pasture started this ought to see how many names standing still can collect."

Two hundred and four. Out of three hundred and twelve houses. I counted the pages first — eleven pages, names in blue ink and black ink, a few in pencil where a kitchen pen had failed and somebody had finished the job with what was at hand. There were addresses. There were lot numbers. Hartley, lot 14, first page, first two lines, Jim's hand and Paula's hand different and side by side. Denise's own name on page three. And near the back, on page nine, a name I read twice to be sure my eyes were not enjoying themselves at my expense.

Pritchard, D.

"When did Don sign?" I asked.

"Tuesday," Denise said. "At the Hartleys' kitchen table. He sat there a long time first. Paula made coffee. He read the title search again — Sam's copy, the whole thing, back to nineteen fifty-two — and Paula said he kept putting his finger on the page where the clerk certified there was no recorded easement across your south pasture, like he was checking the page was real. Then he signed. Then he said — and Paula told me to give you this part exactly — he said, 'Well. There it is, then.'"

Well. There it is, then. For Don Pritchard, who had owned three golf polos and one opinion for as long as I had known him, and whose one opinion had been that Margaret was right, that was a long speech. That was a man setting a heavy thing down.

The vote was set for a Thursday evening at the clubhouse, under the bylaws, with a quorum counted and proxies in envelopes and a parliamentarian the HOA's lawyer had suggested in the hope, I think, that procedure might do what persuasion no longer could. Sam kept me informed the way a man reads weather to another man who has already come in out of the rain. I did not go. It was not my meeting, not my subdivision, not my vote. A slow man knows which rooms are his. Mine was my kitchen, and I stayed in it, and I washed Ruth's old iron skillet, and I listened to the trucks go past on the county road, fewer now that the schedule had settled, and waited for the phone.

It rang at eight forty. Sam.

"The count is running against her two to one and they are not halfway through the room," he said. "She is standing by the secretary's table. Jim Hartley tells me she has taken the visor off. I do not believe he has ever seen her without it. He says it like a man reporting weather damage."

"She'll let it finish," I said. "She likes a procedure."

"She is writing something," Sam said. "Hold on."

I held on. Through the phone I could hear the particular hush of a man listening to another room through a third man, which is to say I heard nothing but Sam breathing, and Ray's dog barking once far off at something on the road, and my own refrigerator making its small old sound.

"Joe," Sam said at last. "She has handed the secretary a letter. She has resigned. President, board seat, all of it, effective immediately. The vote is moot and they are still going to complete the count, because two hundred people did not drive over there to not be counted, but it is done. Margaret Callaway has resigned before the vote could finish removing her. She wanted the last procedural word and she has taken it."

I thought about that for a moment. It was the most Margaret thing left available to her, and I found I could not begrudge it. A person is what they are all the way down. She had treated authority like a crown for years, and at the end she had set it down herself rather than have it taken, and there are worse endings for a reign than that small, stiff scrap of dignity. Not many people were going to be kind about it. I did not have to be one of the unkind ones. She had cut my fence and dug my pasture and lied with a straight face about a piece of paper that did not exist. All of that was true. It just was not the only true thing in my kitchen that night.

"There's more," Sam said. "The apology."

The apology had been under negotiation for nine days, which is a long time to negotiate thirty-one words, but they were thirty-one words that had to do real work. The HOA's insurer was settling Margaret's personal exposure under the directors-and-officers policy, and the settlement structure Sam had built required a written apology from her, signed, delivered to me, and placed in the HOA's records where any resident could read it. Her lawyer had sent a first draft that apologized for "any confusion regarding easement documentation." I had read it at my kitchen table and set it down and said to Sam, "That is an apology for my eyesight," and Sam had laughed and taken it back.

The second draft apologized for "misstatements." The third apologized for "errors in process." Each one was a small, polished stone with nothing inside it.

"What did she sign?" I asked.

Sam read it to me, slow, the way he reads anything that is going into a file.

"'I, Margaret Callaway, acknowledge that no easement across the Merritt Ranch south pasture was ever granted or recorded, that I represented otherwise to the board, to residents, and to the contractor, and that the excavation on Mr. Merritt's land was a trespass for which I am sorry.'"

Thirty-one words, near enough. I counted them twice out of habit while Sam waited. There was no confusion in it. There were no misstatements hiding behind a curtain. Trespass, in plain print, with her name under it.

News in the same category

HOA BUILT A PIPELINE THROUGH MY RANCH—SO I BOUGHT THE SOURCE AND CUT OFF THEIR WATER SUPPLY

45 Part