His memory, though. Earl's memory is a courthouse of its own.
He remembers the year the creek ran backward in a flood — '74, and it didn't run backward, it just rose so fast it seemed to, but Earl remembers the day and the hour and whose mule got loose. He remembers my grandfather's hands. Earl played on the Merritt Ranch as a boy, because his father and my grandfather were neighbors and friends in the years when that word described a working arrangement and not a sentiment: they shared a bull, a branding iron design drawn on a feed sack, and a water deal I would come back to more than once before this business ended.
"Sit down," he said. "You look like a man who's been shown paperwork."
I sat. The porch boards were warm from the day. Down the slope the spring house stood where it has always stood, a low stone building over the spring itself, roofed in tin that June had insisted on painting green — "a spring house should look like something that lives," she'd said — and from it the line runs east, the lawful line, buried along the creek access and out to the county road corridor, carrying water to three hundred and twelve houses whose residents mostly do not know Earl Whitaker's name.
He followed my look. "They're not digging toward the road," he said.
"No."
"They're digging toward my spring house."
"Fourteen flags in my pasture," I said, "and the line of them points like an arrow. Margaret stood in my field with a resolution her own board passed and a plat for the wrong parcel and told me she had an approved easement across my land. Sam called the clerk. The clerk finds nothing recorded. Nothing ever. Earl — I came to ask you straight, because you'll answer straight. Did you ever sign an easement? For the HOA, for Beck, for anybody — a new route, a relocation, anything that lets them come across my pasture to your spring?"
Earl took a breath, which for him is a project with stages, and he let it out slow.
"Josiah Merritt," he said, "I signed one water paper in my life and your lawyer's daddy drew it, no, it was Sam himself, young then. Two thousand nine. The bulk water contract. I sell Sage Hollow water from my spring at eighty-five cents a thousand gallons, they take it through the road corridor line, they maintain their end, I maintain the spring house, and that's the whole of it. I never signed an easement across your pasture. I never signed an easement across anybody's anything except the corridor strip for that line, which was surveyed and recorded and done right, with your father—" he caught himself, an old man's honest slip, "—with you consulted, because the corridor touches the corner of your road frontage and you said yes and signed yes, in Sam's office, and got a copy."
"I remember," I said. I did. 2009. Ruth was alive. She made Sam stay for supper after and told him his coffee would outlive his practice if he wasn't careful.
"What I did not sign," Earl said, tapping one finger on the arm of his chair for each word, "is any paper since. Not for Margaret. Not for that developer, Beck, though his man came out here twice with a folder and a smile and ideas about 'modernizing the supply route.' I told him my supply route was modern enough in 2009 and it remains where God and the survey put it. Not for anybody. If Margaret says Earl Whitaker consented to a new line across your land, Margaret is lying, or Margaret has been lied to and liked the sound of it so well she didn't check. Those are the only two Earl Whitakers there are on this subject, and I'm the one with the oxygen, so you can trust the inventory."
The tank hissed. A meadowlark did something complicated down by the creek, showing off.
"You knew about the digging this morning," I said. "Did anybody tell you beforehand? A notice? A courtesy?"
"A courtesy," Earl repeated, tasting the word like a bad tooth. "Tuesday, Don Pritchard's boy — no, Don himself — drove up that drive in a golf cart, Josiah. A golf cart, on caliche. Said there'd be 'utility work in the area' this week and I might hear machinery and not to be alarmed. In the area. He looked at my spring house the whole time he said it, the way a man looks at a pie on a sill while explaining he hasn't come for pie."
"What does your contract say, Earl, about moving the line? Exactly, if you remember it."
"Section Seven," he said, without pausing to think, and I believed the number before he explained it because Earl has always been a man who reads the whole of anything he signs, twice, aloud the second time, June used to say, so the walls would know too. "Delivery only through the recorded road-corridor easement. Any diversion or relocation of the delivery route without the source owner's written consent is a material breach. Source owner — that's me. Written consent — that's the thing that doesn't exist. And Section Eleven is the teeth. Source owner may terminate on sixty days' written notice following an uncured material breach."
"Sixty days," I said.
"Sixty days' written notice, following a breach they don't cure. Sam drew those clauses because I asked what happened if the subdivision ever decided my spring was theirs and the taking of water was just paperwork. Sam said, 'Earl, we write it so that the paper is yours.' So we did."
He turned his head and looked at me directly then, and his eyes were the clear, pale blue of a man who has spent eighty-one years mostly outdoors, and they were not confused and they were not afraid.