HOA BUILT A PIPELINE THROUGH MY RANCH—SO I BOUGHT THE SOURCE AND CUT OFF THEIR WATER SUPPLY

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The Halloway County Courthouse is limestone and steps and a flag that snaps in any wind worth the name, and I have been in it for deeds, for jury duty, for Ruth's and my marriage license a lifetime ago, and to pay taxes in the years before paying taxes became a thing a man did alone with a computer. It has the smell all such buildings have — old paper, floor wax, and other people's urgency.

Judge Carla Reyes hears cases in the district courtroom on the second floor. Sam had told me about her on the drive over, the way he tells me about weather coming: factually, and as a warning to dress appropriately. "Reyes is fair, she's fast, and she hates being managed. She'll read everything in the file before we stand up, so don't perform for her, Joe. Answer what's asked. Count what's true. She can tell the difference between a witness and a salesman at fifty paces and she charges salesmen by the embarrassment."

Our application was for a temporary restraining order: stop the digging, stop the entry, keep every HOA officer, contractor, and machine off the Merritt Ranch until a full hearing could decide the rest. In the hallway before we were called, I saw Margaret.

She had traded the visor for court — hair done, a jacket the color of good intentions, the clipboard nowhere in sight, replaced by a slim folder held in both hands like an offering. Don Pritchard stood at her shoulder in a tie, his sunglasses gone, his smirk entirely gone, wearing the expression of a man who has been told by a lawyer in the parking lot that nodding is not a legal strategy. With them stood the HOA's counsel, the city firm, a young man in a suit that cost more than my truck's last transmission, speaking quietly and urgently into the side of Margaret's attention while she stared straight ahead at the courtroom doors, watching them the way you watch a weather front.

When she saw me, her face did a complicated thing. It began with the traffic-cop certainty of the pasture — chin up, ready to instruct. Then something in it checked, the way a horse checks at a shadow it can't read. She had expected, I think, to find me as she'd left me: an old man in a field, outnumbered by machinery. She had not expected the field to arrive in her world wearing a clean shirt, with Sam Whitfield carrying a box.

"Mr. Merritt," she said, as if greeting a constituent.

"Mrs. Callaway," I said, and tipped my head, and walked past with Sam, because there was nothing in that hallway that needed saying that wasn't already written down and signed somewhere in his box.

Judge Reyes is a woman in her fifties with gray coming into dark hair and the reading glasses of a person who uses them as punctuation. She had read the file. That was apparent in the first ninety seconds, because she did not let the city lawyer finish his third sentence about "emergency utility necessity" before she raised one finger — not a palm; Judge Reyes does not stop traffic, she simply stops time — and said:

"Counsel, before we get to necessity, we'll get to right. Show me the recorded easement."

"Your Honor, the association's Resolution 24-07—"

"I have read the resolution." The glasses came off. "It is a resolution of a homeowners association authorizing itself. I asked for the recorded easement. The instrument. Signed by the landowner, filed with the clerk of this county, giving your client a right across Mr. Merritt's land."

There was a silence in that courtroom of the sort that makes a man aware of his own breathing. The young lawyer looked down at his notes as if the instrument might be hiding between the pages, shy.

"Your Honor, the recording is — the administrative process was still being—"

"Completed?" the judge said.

"—finalized."

"I see." Judge Reyes turned a page in her own file, though I believe she knew every word on it already and the turning was for the room's benefit, the way a slow man counts flags: so that everyone understands a reckoning is being done in order. "Mr. Whitfield. Your clerk's certification."

Sam stood. He does not hurry when he stands; he assembles. "Certified records search, Halloway County Clerk, Your Honor, in the packet at tab two. No easement, license, or right-of-way across the Merritt south pasture has ever been recorded. Not in Mr. Merritt's name, not in his father's, not in his grandfather's, back to the original deed records of 1952. The only recorded water easement in this matter is the 2009 road-corridor easement, tab three — which is where the subdivision's water line lawfully runs, and where, undisputed, this trench is not."

"Mr. Lindqvist's survey," the judge said.

"Tab four, Your Honor. County surveyor. The trench and the flag line cross Mr. Merritt's land and run toward Whitaker Spring. At no point do they come within a quarter mile of the recorded corridor."

"And the plat attached to the resolution."

Sam allowed himself the smallest pause. "References Sage Hollow Phase Two, Lot One, Your Honor. Land the association's developer owns. Not Mr. Merritt's parcel. Their one piece of paper, for the wrong piece of ground."

The judge looked at Margaret then. Judges look at parties the way veterinarians look at an animal's owner — not for the story, which the lawyers have already dressed up, but for the condition of the creature itself. "Mrs. Callaway, I am going to ask you a plain question and I would like a plain answer. Before your contractor cut Mr. Merritt's fence, did you or anyone on your board ever see a document signed by Mr. Merritt, or by any Merritt, granting this easement?"

Margaret rose, because she is a woman who rises to speak in rooms — committees have taught her that standing is authority. "Your Honor, the board relied on the developer's representations that the route had been approved and cleared. The subdivision faces a genuine emergency with its water supply. Two main breaks last year alone. We acted to protect three hundred and twelve homes—"

"That was not my question," Judge Reyes said, not unkindly, which somehow made it worse for Margaret; unkindness she could have resented, and resentment is a kind of fuel. "My question was whether you ever saw a Merritt signature. Yes or no will do nicely."

"...No, Your Honor."

"No. And yet the fence was cut on your authorization."

"On the board's resolution—"

"Which the board wrote itself." The glasses went back on. "Thank you, Mrs. Callaway. You may sit down."

News in the same category

HOA BUILT A PIPELINE THROUGH MY RANCH—SO I BOUGHT THE SOURCE AND CUT OFF THEIR WATER SUPPLY

45 Part