Margaret stood too, fast, visor catching the kitchen light. "You are willing to turn off water to three hundred and twelve homes over a negotiation?" she said.
"No," I said. "I am willing to enforce a contract your board signed, after a breach your board committed, on a clock your own contract set. The water was never yours to aim at my land, Margaret. If it stops, it will stop at a valve, on a day everybody at this table can count to, with Sam beside me and the paperwork in order. That is not a threat. Threats do not come with certified mail receipts."
Don gathered the twelve pages. I noticed he gathered them slowly and squared them, and did not hand them to Austin, but carried them out himself, holding them in both hands, like a man carrying something he had finally decided to read all the way to the end.
When their vehicles had gone down my drive, Sam stayed for a second cup.
"You know they will come back with a real number," he said. "After Day Sixty, most likely, when the hauling bills start. Pride is expensive before the water stops. It gets downright educational after."
"They had a chance to count in private," I said. "At their own tables, with their own pencils. A man who will not count in private ends up counting in public, with an audience."
I washed the cups. Five cups. I counted them into the rack the way I count everything else, because a number told honestly is a kind of promise, and I intended to keep every one of mine.
The recall petition started, as most honest things in that subdivision started that month, at Paula Hartley's kitchen table.
Denise brought me a copy on the Monday after the failed negotiation, not because I had any vote in Sage Hollow — I do not, and I would not take one if it were offered in a gift bag — but because she said a man whose name is on the first page of the story ought to be able to read the page where the neighbors start writing back.
The petition was plain. It named Margaret Callaway. It stated that the board, under her presidency, had authorized work on private land without a recorded easement, had represented that authorization to residents as approved and recorded, and had exposed the association to termination of its water contract. It called for a recall vote under the HOA's own bylaws. It had lines for signatures, with lot numbers. Paula, being Paula, had ruled the lines herself with a straightedge. Jim told me later she had thrown out the first draft because the margins were uneven.
"How many did you get the first weekend?" I asked Denise.
"Eighty-seven," she said.
I raised my eyebrows. She shook her head before I could turn it into arithmetic.
"Do not ask me what number we need, Mr. Merritt, because Jim and Paula are counting that out of the bylaws themselves and I will not carry you a number I have not watched them count twice. I will tell you what I saw. I saw people sign at the Hartleys' table, and at the mailbox cluster on our street, and one man signed in the clinic parking lot and then went home and got his wife, because she said her name belonged on it as much as his. That is what I saw."
That is a kind of counting too. I did not correct it.
Copies moved through Sage Hollow the way weather moves through a county: not everywhere at once, but nobody out of its reach for long. A copy at the clubhouse, under a magnet, until it was taken down and then, the next morning, back up again under two magnets. A copy carried door to door by a retired schoolteacher whose name I never learned, in a tote bag. A copy in the Hartleys' garage, where Jim, who writes everything down, kept the signed sheets in a folder that he labeled, Paula told Sam, in block letters: PAPER THAT IS RECORDED. He meant it as a joke. It was the driest joke told in Sage Hollow that year, and it came from a man learning, late, to be angry accurately.
Don Pritchard read the title search on a Wednesday.
I know that because he told me so himself, standing in my drive on Thursday morning, holding the twelve pages of the HOA's insulting offer in one hand and a thick stapled document in the other, with his sunglasses, for the first time in my acquaintance with him, nowhere on his head at all.
"Can I come up?" he said.
"You are up," I said. "The porch is a step farther. Take it."
He sat where Earl sits, which would ordinarily have annoyed me, and did not, because Don was not occupying the chair the way Don occupied chairs beside Margaret, with his smirk set like a place card. He looked like a man who had sat up all night in a chair of his own and not enjoyed the company.
"I asked Austin's office for the full file," he said. "Our file. The association's. I am a board member, I can ask. Nobody ever told me I could not ask. Margaret just—" He turned the thick document over in his hands. "She gave summaries. At meetings she gave summaries. One page. Resolution, action item, vote. I read the summaries for three years, Joe. I want that said plainly first. I read what I was handed and I nodded at what I was handed and I wore—" He stopped, and looked out at the south pasture, where the trench still ran like a sentence nobody had finished. "I had a second opinion about a lot of things, over the years. Golf shirts. I own three. Opinions I owned one. It was issued to me."
"Don," I said. "Say what you came to say. Slow is fine. Slow is how a man gets it said right."
"I read the title search last night," he said. "All of it. Sam's search, and the clerk's index, and the 2009 contract. Section Seven. Section Eleven. I read the deed history back to 1952. Your grandfather. There is no easement, Joe. There has never been an easement. I sat in my kitchen and I went looking through three years of board packets for the page where anybody — anybody — showed us a recorded easement, and the page is not there, because it does not exist. What exists is Margaret telling us in March that the developer had secured the route years ago. I remember her saying it. I remember me nodding. I have a very clear memory of nodding."