"Sam Whitfield calling. I'm sitting here with Joe Merritt. I need a records check and I need it thorough. Any recorded easement, utility or otherwise, across the Merritt south pasture — grantor Merritt, any first name, Walter, Thomas, or Josiah — grantee Sage Hollow, or the HOA, or Beck Development, or Brener, or anybody at all. Any year."
Keys clicked on her end. Sam waited. Waiting is most of lawyering, he has told me for decades, and the rest is reading. She went away and came back, went away longer the second time, and when she came back her voice had that particular flatness of a person who has looked in every drawer the question could live in.
"Sam, there's nothing," she said. "There's the old road-corridor utility easement, recorded oh-nine, that's the water line to the subdivision from the Whitaker spring, that's on the road. There's your client's grandfather's deed records and the mineral reservation from the fifties. There's nothing across that south pasture. No easement, no license, no right-of-way filing. Not under Merritt. Not under the subdivision's name. Not under Beck. If somebody recorded a paper giving Sage Hollow the right to dig up Joe Merritt's grass, they recorded it in some other county, because it is not in Halloway."
"Say that last part again slower, for my notes," Sam said, and she did, and he wrote it down word for word and read it back to her, and she confirmed it.
"Thank you. Send me a certified records search when you can. Bill my office."
"You know I will," she said, and hung up.
Sam set the receiver down gentle, like it was a tool he'd need again, which it was.
"There it is," he said. "Nothing recorded. Nothing at all. Which means that this morning, Margaret Callaway ordered a contractor into your pasture on the strength of her own board's resolution and a plat of the wrong parcel, and Ray Brener cut a fence he had no right to cut."
"Brener may not know that."
"He may not," Sam allowed. "Ray Brener has run dirt in this county twenty years and I've never heard him called a thief. Careless about whose paper he trusts, maybe he'll turn out to be. But Margaret knows, or somebody behind Margaret knows. A wrong parcel number is not an accident that happens to dig in a straight line toward a spring, Joe. Somebody drew that line on purpose and then went looking for paper to lay over it."
"What do I do?"
"Today, three things. First, I write a letter — today, hand-delivered and certified — putting the HOA and Brener Excavation on formal notice of trespass and demanding they stop and restore. Second, we get Pete Lindqvist out to survey your lines, so nobody can make this a boundary argument in front of a judge. Third—" he looked at me over the glasses — "you go see Earl."
"Earl."
"The trench runs at his spring, Joe. If they're building a new route to his water that doesn't pass through the recorded corridor, then either Earl sold them something nobody recorded — which the clerk would still not have, if it was never filed, but Earl would know — or they're helping themselves to his spring the same way they're helping themselves to your pasture. Either way, Earl Whitaker is the other end of that trench. You need to hear from Earl himself what he signed and what he didn't, and what that 2009 contract of his actually says. I have a copy from the platting days in a file box, but Earl's copy is the executed one with his signature, and Earl's memory—"
"Earl's memory is better than yours and mine put together," I said.
"That," Sam said, "is exactly why you're going."
He wrote his letter while I sat there. Lawyers say they will write a letter the way other men say they will fix a gate — it can mean this week or this season — but Sam wrote it at the desk with me watching, two pages, plain language wrapped in the kind of sentences that have consequences, and he read me the heart of it aloud: unauthorized entry, cut fence, demand to cease all work and remove all equipment from the Merritt Ranch, reservation of all claims for damages. He signed it with the fountain pen his father left him, which he reserves for documents he expects to be read twice.
"One more thing," he said, as I stood to go. "They will write back at you. People like Margaret, when the paper turns out to be thin, they don't retreat — they generate more paper. Fines, violations, notices. It will feel personal because it will be. Don't answer any of it yourself. Bring it to me, unopened if your temper requires it, opened if it doesn't. And Joe—" he waited until I met his eye — "whatever they dig tomorrow, you photograph it, and you keep your hands and your voice exactly where they were this morning. Slow."
"A slow man has time to look," I said.
"I've heard that somewhere," Sam said, and almost smiled, and I left him to his letter and his terrible coffee and drove west to Earl's before the light went.
Earl Whitaker's twelve acres lie west of the creek, up a caliche drive that floods in a hard rain and rattles a truck the rest of the year, and his house sits at the top of it looking east over the water and, beyond the creek, over the back of my south pasture. From Earl's porch you can see my grass. That is a fact that mattered later and it mattered that afternoon, because Earl had been watching my pasture all day through a pair of binoculars June gave him for bird-watching the year before she died, and he knew about the excavator before I finished parking.
"Thought you'd be here by noon," he said from the porch. "You're slowing down, Josiah."
"I stopped to be insulted by a lawyer first," I said. "It takes time out of a day."
Earl is eighty-one and thin in the way of men whose bodies have started spending savings. The oxygen was with him — a portable tank in its little wheeled carrier beside his chair, the clear tube running to his nose, hissing soft every breath or so. At home he has a machine in the bedroom that makes the stuff out of room air, a marvel he describes as "a refrigerator that learned one trick." His lung is bad and getting no better and Earl speaks of it the way a rancher speaks of a fence he knows he'll be mending the rest of his life: as a condition to work around, not a subject for sympathy. Woe betide the visitor who tries sympathy. Carol, his daughter in Dallas, tried arranging a home aide by telephone last spring and Earl fired the woman by telephone himself before she ever got on the road, politely, with references to his ability to boil his own egg.