"She did that three times," Olivia said. "I wrote it down. Tuesdays and Thursdays, when Clara was in the garden. I thought at first Clara was just forgetting. Then I saw Vanessa do it on the camera, and I knew."
I felt sick. It was such a small cruelty, moving a bottle out of reach, and that was what made it so terrible. It was not a moment of anger. It was a habit. It was a woman deciding, again and again, that a baby's hunger was a tool she could use to make another woman look careless.
We watched more. On a Thursday afternoon, Emma was crying in her crib, the long, tired cry that means she is overtired and needs to be held, and Clara was upstairs changing the beds. Vanessa stood in the hallway outside the nursery for almost four minutes. The camera caught her in profile, her arms folded, her phone in one hand, looking at the nursery door as if she were waiting for something. She did not go in. She did not call for Clara. She stood there and listened to the baby cry, and when Clara came down the stairs with the laundry basket, Vanessa turned away and walked into the kitchen, as if she had only just arrived. Clara went straight into the nursery and picked Emma up, and the crying stopped within a minute, the way it always stopped when Clara held her. I remembered that afternoon. I had come home that evening and Vanessa had told me Emma had been fussy all day and Clara seemed overwhelmed. I had believed her. I had asked Clara if she needed help, and Clara had said no, she was fine, and I had thought I was being a good employer. I had not understood that I was being managed.
Olivia kept notes in a school notebook, the same notebook she used for her maths homework, and she wrote the dates and times in her neat, careful handwriting. She did not cry while we watched. She was angry in the quiet way she gets angry, the way her mother used to get angry, with her jaw set and her eyes very clear. I was proud of her and I was furious with myself in equal measure, because a twelve-year-old girl had done the work I should have done. She had noticed. She had set up a camera. She had kept a record. She had protected her sister when the adults in the house had failed to.
On the third day we watched, we found the note. Clara had left a note on the fridge for me, the way she always did when Emma needed something — a note in her careful handwriting saying Emma was almost out of nappies and the paediatrician's number was on the counter. The camera showed Vanessa reading the note while she waited for the kettle, folding it in half, and then putting it in her pocket. She did not throw it away in the kitchen bin, where Clara might have seen it. She took it with her, and later that day I came home and found Emma in a nappy that was too small, and Clara apologising, and Vanessa saying Clara must have forgotten to tell me. I remembered Clara's face that evening, confused and a little hurt, because she knew she had written the note. I remembered thinking she was getting older, getting forgetful. I remembered Vanessa putting her hand on my arm and saying, gently, that perhaps Clara needed fewer hours. It had sounded like concern. On the screen, in the cold light of the footage, it looked like something else entirely. It looked like a plan.
"She wanted you to fire Clara," Olivia said. She did not look up from her notebook. "She told me once that Clara was too old and that Emma would be better with a proper nanny. A younger one. Someone she could choose."
I asked Olivia when Vanessa had said that, and she told me it was on a Saturday, when I was at the office, and Vanessa had been looking at nannies on her phone. She had shown Olivia photographs of young women in smart uniforms and asked her which one she liked best, as if choosing a nanny were like choosing a dress. Olivia had said she liked Clara. Vanessa had smiled and said Clara was lovely, but lovely was not the same as suitable, and a baby needed someone modern. Olivia had not told me at the time because she had thought it was only an opinion, and because she did not want to cause trouble before the wedding. She told me now, and I could hear the guilt in her voice, the guilt of a child who thinks she should have spoken sooner, and I put my hand over hers on the table and told her she had done nothing wrong. She had done everything right. The trouble had been caused by Vanessa, not by her.