Ellen Brooks told me three things that afternoon, and I have remembered them ever since. First, that the footage was strong, because it was original, time-stamped, and corroborated by Olivia, Clara, and Mrs. Delgado. Second, that Vanessa's lawyer's letter was weak, because it made claims it could not prove and threatened custody it had no right to seek. Third, that I needed to protect the evidence, because evidence is the only thing that stands up when people start lying. She took the original camera files and made a forensic copy, sealed and dated, and she stored the originals in her office safe. She wrote to Vanessa's lawyer the same day, a short, calm letter saying that we would not be withdrawing anything, that all further communication should go through her, and that any attempt to contact Olivia or Clara directly would be reported to the police. She told me not to answer Vanessa's calls, not to meet her alone, not to try to reason with her, because reason was not what this was about. This was about a woman who had tried to harm a baby and was now trying to harm the people who had stopped her.
That night, after Olivia and Emma were asleep, I sat in the living room with Clara, and we talked about what would happen next. Clara told me she had been thinking about leaving, not because she wanted to leave, but because she was afraid her presence in the house would make things harder for me, that Vanessa's lawyer would use her against me, that the police would think she had a reason to lie. I told her she was not leaving. I told her this was her home as much as it was mine, and that if anyone tried to use her, they would have to go through me and through Ellen Brooks and through Detective Kim, and that I would not let that happen. She nodded, and she did not argue, but I could see she was still afraid, and I understood why. She had spent her whole working life being invisible, being the person in the background who kept everything running, and now she was in the foreground, and the foreground is a frightening place when you are not used to it. I told her she did not have to be brave on her own. We would be brave together.
The next day, Detective Kim came back to the house. She had interviewed Vanessa, she said, at her sister's apartment, with her lawyer present. Vanessa had denied everything. She had said the stroller had rolled on its own, that the floor was uneven, that Clara had left it too close to the stairs, that she had been the one trying to save Emma, not the one who had put her in danger. She had said Olivia was confused, and Clara was jealous, and I was grieving and not thinking clearly. Detective Kim had listened to all of it, and then she had shown Vanessa the footage, and Vanessa had gone quiet, and her lawyer had asked for a break. That was when Detective Kim knew, she told me, that the case was real. People who are innocent get angry when they are shown evidence against them. People who are guilty go quiet, because they are calculating what to say next.
Detective Kim had also spoken to Mrs. Delgado, and to the paediatrician, and to the woman at the nursery where Emma sometimes went for two hours on a Friday morning. The nursery woman had said Emma was always happy when Clara brought her, and quiet and withdrawn when Vanessa brought her, and she had noticed it but had not known what to make of it. Small things, again, each one small on its own, each one part of a pattern when you put them together. Detective Kim was building the pattern, piece by piece, the way Olivia and I had built it in the kitchen, and I felt a strange, grim relief, because for the first time since the stroller, I was not the only person who believed what had happened.
Vanessa's messages continued, but they changed. The apologies stopped. The threats stopped. Instead, there were long, rambling messages in the middle of the night, saying she could not sleep, saying she had made a mistake, saying she needed help, saying she had not meant for any of it to happen. I did not reply to those either, on Ellen Brooks's advice, but I read them, and I saved them, and I wondered what was true in them and what was performance. I had loved this woman. I had asked her to marry me. I had imagined her as Emma's mother, as Olivia's stepmother, as the person who would sit beside me at the kitchen table for the rest of my life. Now I was reading her messages at two in the morning and trying to decide whether she was a person who had made a terrible mistake, or a person who had planned a terrible thing and was now afraid of being caught. I did not know the answer, and I was beginning to understand that I might never know it, and that the answer did not change what I had to do. Whatever she had meant, Emma had been in danger, and my job was to make sure she was never in danger again.