Then Detective Kim sat with Clara, in the kitchen, with tea, and Clara told her everything she had suspected and everything she had seen, in her careful, honest way, without adding anything she was not sure of. She told the detective about the bottle, and the note, and the monitor, and the garden, and the way Vanessa had spoken to her when no one else was listening. She told her about the fear of losing her job, and the fear of losing the girls, and the detective listened the same way she had listened to me, without interrupting, and when Clara finished, the detective said, "You did the right thing by staying. You kept that baby safe. That matters." Clara nodded, and I saw her shoulders come down a little, as if she had been carrying something heavy for a very long time and someone had finally offered to help her carry it.
Detective Kim took the footage. She took the laptop, and the camera, and the memory card, and she made a list of everything she was taking, and she had me sign it, and she gave me a copy. She was careful and professional, and she did not promise me anything she could not promise. She said she would open an investigation for child endangerment, and that she would interview Vanessa, and that she would need to speak to Olivia again, perhaps with a specialist present, and that she would keep me informed. She said Emma was safe now, and that was the most important thing, and she said if Vanessa contacted me, I should not reply in anger, I should keep the messages and show them to her. I told her I would. I walked her to the door, and she paused on the step and looked back at the house, at the stairs where the stroller had almost rolled, and she said, "You came home just in time. A few seconds later, and we would be having a very different conversation." I nodded, because I had been thinking the same thing every minute since that afternoon, and I did not trust myself to say it out loud.
That evening, Vanessa began to message me. The first messages were apologies. She was sorry. She had been stressed. The wedding, the house, the baby, it had all been too much. She had not meant to push the stroller, she had only been trying to move it out of the way, and Clara had overreacted, and Olivia had misunderstood. She loved Emma. She loved Olivia. She loved me. She wanted to come home and talk. I read the messages with Olivia beside me, and we did not reply. The second set of messages, an hour later, were different. She was angry. She said I had humiliated her. She said I had chosen a housekeeper over my fiancée. She said Clara had always been jealous of her, and Olivia had always been difficult, and I would regret this. She said her family would hear about it. She said I did not know who I was dealing with. I saved every message, the way Detective Kim had told me to, and I did not answer any of them.
The third set of messages came the next morning, and they were not from Vanessa. They were from a lawyer. A letter, sent by email, on headed paper, claiming that Clara had manipulated the footage, that Olivia was a troubled child who was lying to protect Clara, that Vanessa had been the victim of a campaign by a jealous housekeeper, and that if I did not withdraw my statement to the police, Vanessa would sue me for defamation and seek custody of Emma. Custody of Emma. A baby who was not hers, whose mother had died, whose father was standing in his own kitchen reading a lawyer's letter threatening to take her away. I read it twice, and then I put the phone down on the table very carefully, because I was afraid I would throw it across the room, and Olivia, who had been watching my face, said, "Dad, are you all right?" I told her I was all right, and that the letter was only words, and that words could not take Emma away from us, but my hands were shaking, and she could see it.
I called a lawyer that morning. Her name was Ellen Brooks, and she had been recommended to me by a colleague at work whose brother had gone through a difficult custody case. She answered the phone herself, which I liked, and she listened to the whole story without rushing me, and then she said, "Bring me everything. Bring the footage, bring the camera, bring the messages, bring the lawyer's letter. Do not reply to any of it until I have seen it." I drove to her office that afternoon, with the laptop and the memory card and a printed copy of every message Vanessa had sent, and she went through it all with me, page by page, clip by clip, and she did not look shocked. She looked focused, the way a good lawyer looks when she is building a case, and that steadied me more than sympathy would have done.