Then I heard a sound from the stairs. A small sound, a footstep, and I looked up. Olivia was standing on the stairs. My twelve-year-old daughter. She was holding her phone in one hand, and her knuckles were white around it, and her face was ashen, the colour gone out of it completely, as if she had seen something she could not unsee. She was looking down at us, at her father holding her baby sister, at Clara standing with empty hands, at Vanessa crying beside me, and she did not look like a child. She looked like someone much older, someone who had been carrying a secret and had just decided she could not carry it any longer.
"Olivia," I said, "go to your room."
She did not move. She did not go to her room. She walked down the stairs, slowly, one step at a time, still holding her phone, still pale, still looking at Vanessa in a way I had never seen her look at anyone before. Vanessa saw her coming and her crying stopped for a second, just a second, and in that second I saw something cross her face. It was not fear. It was not relief. It was something else, something I could not name yet, something that made my stomach turn.
Olivia reached the bottom of the stairs. She did not look at me. She did not look at Clara. She looked at Vanessa, and then she looked at the television on the wall, and she tapped her phone, and the screen came to life. The hallway security camera footage filled the television, and the room went silent. Emma had stopped crying. She was still hiccuping against my chest, but she was quiet now, listening, as if she knew that something important was about to happen. Clara was standing very still. Vanessa was standing very still. And I was standing very still, holding my baby, watching my twelve-year-old daughter show me the truth about what had happened in my house while I was at work.
The footage was in colour, but it looked grey to me, as if the light had been taken out of it. The timestamp in the corner said the afternoon, the time I had been driving home, thinking about dinner and about Olivia's history test. The hallway was empty at first. The stroller was where Clara always left it, by the wall near the living room, with Emma in it, sleeping, her blanket tucked around her. I could see Emma's small face on the screen, peaceful, her mouth open a little, her hand curled near her cheek. She had been asleep. She had been safe. And then Vanessa walked into the frame.
She was not running. She was not frightened. She was walking slowly, calmly, as if she had all the time in the world. She looked down the hallway first, toward the kitchen, and then toward the stairs, and then she put both hands on the handle of the stroller. I watched her hands. I watched the way her fingers wrapped around the handle, the way she adjusted her grip, the way she looked at Emma for a moment, and then looked away, as if she did not want to see her face. And then she pushed.
It was not a hard push. It was not violent. It was steady, deliberate, the kind of push a person gives when they want something to roll away from them and not come back. The stroller began to move toward the stairs. The wheels turned slowly at first, and then faster, and Emma woke up, and her face changed, and she began to cry, and the stroller kept rolling, and Vanessa stood there and watched it go. She did not reach for it. She did not call out. She stood there with her hands at her sides, watching my baby roll toward the stairs, and then she took a step back, and then another, as if she wanted to be far enough away that no one could say she had been near it.
And then Clara came running from the kitchen. I had never seen Clara run like that. She was not a young woman, and her knees hurt her in the winter, and she always moved carefully, slowly, as if she was saving her strength for the things that mattered. But in that footage she ran like a mother runs, like a person runs when there is no time to think and only time to move. She came out of the kitchen with a dish towel still in her hand, and she saw the stroller, and she dropped the towel, and she dove. She dove across the floor, and she caught the stroller inches from the edge of the top step, her hands closing around the frame just as the front wheel went over. The stroller tipped, and she held it, and she pulled it back, and she pulled Emma out of it, and she curled herself around my baby on the floor, and she held her, and she was shaking, and she was pale, and she was crying, and she was saying something I could not hear on the footage, something soft, over and over, probably Emma's name, probably "I have you, I have you, I have you."