On the anniversary of that day, three years later, I read the account aloud to Olivia and Clara. Emma was in nursery school that morning, and the house was quiet in a way it had not been quiet for a long time. I had asked Olivia if she wanted to hear it, and she had said yes, in the steady way she says yes to things that matter, and Clara had made tea and sat in her usual chair by the window, the one with the cushion she had sewn herself. I read slowly. My voice shook at the beginning, at the part about the hallway, and Olivia reached across and put her hand over mine, and I kept going. I read about the stroller, about the wheels, about Clara's dive, about the way Emma had cried and then, impossibly, had laughed when Clara held her up in the air and called her a little bird. I read about the camera, about the screen, about the trial. I read about the day I had come home and found my family still standing, and about the day I had understood that the family that remained was the real one. When I finished, none of us spoke for a while. Clara wiped her eyes with the corner of her apron, even though she had not worn an apron for years, and Olivia leaned her head against my shoulder, and the tea went cold in the cups, and the light moved across the floor, and it felt, for the first time, like a story that belonged to us and not to the woman who had tried to take it from us.
Afterwards I put the notebook in a wooden box with Emma's late mother's photographs. I had kept those photographs in a drawer for years, taking them out on birthdays and on quiet evenings, and now I laid them carefully at the bottom of the box, the way you lay down something precious, and I put the notebook on top of them, and I closed the lid. I told Olivia that the box was hers and Emma's whenever they wanted it, that there was nothing in it they could not ask me about, that the truth was not a secret in this house anymore. She nodded, and she asked if she could write something on the lid, and I gave her a pen, and she wrote, in her neat, careful hand, the date of Emma's fourth birthday, and underneath it, in smaller letters, the words our family. I looked at those words for a long time. Our family. It had taken us three years to be able to write them without flinching.
Emma started nursery school that September. I walked her there on the first morning, holding her small hand, carrying her pink backpack with the broken zip, and she talked the whole way, about the teacher, about the sandpit, about a boy who had a red lunchbox, about the fact that she was four now and four-year-olds did not need to be carried. When we reached the gate she turned and looked at me, and for a moment I saw her as a baby again, small and soft in the stroller, and then she was four again, solid and sure of herself, and she said, "Daddy, you can go now," in the tone of a person giving an instruction, and I laughed, and I kissed the top of her head, and I watched her walk through the gate without looking back. I stood there for a while after she had gone, watching the other parents, watching the teachers, watching the small bright building, and I thought about how far we had come from the day when I had been afraid to leave her alone in a room. Clara was waiting for me when I got home, standing at the door with her hands on her hips, and she said, "Well, did she cry?" and I said, "No, she told me to go," and Clara laughed so hard she had to sit down, and she said, "That child has your stubbornness and my good sense, which is a dangerous combination," and we both laughed, and the house felt full even though Emma was gone for the morning.