Olivia's fifteenth year was a year of becoming. She grew taller, and quieter in some ways, and louder in others, and she began to talk about the future in a way she had not talked about it before. She talked about studying film, about making stories that told the truth, about working with children, about going to a university far away and coming home for Christmas with stories to tell. She talked about her mother, too, more than she had before, asking me questions about the woman who had died when Emma was born, about what she had liked, about what she had laughed at, about whether Emma had her eyes. I told her everything I could remember, and when I could not remember, I said so, and she did not mind. She said, "It is enough to know she loved us, Dad," and I said, "She did, more than anything," and she nodded, and she went back to her homework, and I sat at the kitchen table for a while, thinking about the two women who had shaped my daughters' lives, one who had given them life and left too soon, and one who had tried to take a life and had been stopped by a housekeeper with a tea towel in her hand. I thought about how strange it was that the worst person we had known and the best person we had known had both been in our hallway on the same day, and that the house had kept the best one and let the other one go.
In the winter of that third year, I took Olivia and Emma to visit the place where their mother was buried. We went on a cold, bright morning, with white roses, because their mother had loved white roses, and Emma carried one in each hand, very carefully, as though they might break. Olivia laid the roses on the stone, and she stood there for a while with her hands in her pockets, and she said, "Mum, Emma is four now, and she is brave, and I won an award for a film, and Dad wrote our story down, and Clara is still with us, and we are all right." Emma put her small hand on the stone and said, "Hello, Mummy," in a clear, high voice, and then she looked at me and said, "Is she in the sky, Daddy?" and I said, "I think she is wherever love is, and love is here," and Emma nodded, and she took my hand, and we walked back to the car, and the cold air made our cheeks pink, and the sky was very blue, and I felt, for the first time in years, that grief and happiness could sit side by side in the same heart without one having to push the other out.
The house itself changed in those three years, in small, practical ways. We painted the hallway a warm yellow, the colour of morning, and we put a runner on the stairs, thick and soft, with a pattern of small leaves. We put a gate at the top of the stairs, not because we were afraid, but because Emma was four and four-year-olds run, and Clara said a gate was sensible, and sensible was a word Clara used the way other people used the word love. We put a photograph of Emma's mother on the wall in the living room, beside the photograph of Olivia on the stairs, and a photograph of Clara in the garden, holding a tomato like a trophy, and a photograph of the four of us at Emma's birthday, with icing on our noses and balloons in the hedge. The house filled up with photographs, with drawings, with books, with the small, ordinary clutter of a family that was living its life instead of guarding it. The locked drawer in my study, with Vanessa's unopened letter inside it, was the only thing in the house that stayed closed, and I was glad of that. Some doors are meant to stay shut.
Adrian, I told myself, on the morning of the third anniversary, you have done the hard thing. You have kept your daughters safe. You have told the truth. You have let the law do its work. You have let Clara become family. You have let Olivia become herself. You have let Emma become four. You have written the story down. Now you must live the rest of it. I stood in the hallway that morning, looking at the staircase, looking at the photograph of Emma on the third step, looking at the runner with the small leaves, and I thought about the day I had come home just in time. I thought about the sound of the wheels. I thought about Clara's hands. I thought about Olivia's phone. I thought about the screen in the police room. I thought about the trial, and the sentence, and the letter I had written once and never again. I thought about all of it, and then I let it go, the way you let go of a breath you have been holding for a long time, and I went into the kitchen, where Clara was making porridge, and Emma was trying to pour milk without spilling it, and Olivia was reading the newspaper, and the day began, ordinary and bright and ours.