Victoria was not cruel to him. I want to be fair about that, even now. She loved him in her own way. She chose his clothes with care. She held him for photographs. She took him to parties and showed him off, and she was proud of him, in the way a woman is proud of a beautiful thing she owns. But she did not sit on the nursery floor. She did not rock him when he cried. She did not know what frightened him at night, or what made him laugh until his sides hurt. She had a life of her own, and it was a busy one. There were luncheons and charity boards and committees and friends, and there was always somewhere she had to be. She was gone most days, and when she was home she was tired, and when she was tired she did not want a small boy clinging to her skirts.
I remember his third birthday, a few weeks before everything fell apart. Victoria was at a luncheon, and I was in the city, and Rosa made him a small cake in the kitchen, chocolate, with three candles, and she sang to him in her soft voice while he blew them out. He got chocolate on his chin and on his shirt, and she laughed, and she wiped it off with a cloth, and she told him to make a wish. He wished, very solemnly, with his eyes squeezed shut, and when I asked him later what he had wished for, he said he had wished that Rosa would always be there. I laughed when he told me. I thought it was a sweet thing for a child to say. I did not know that in a few weeks he would learn how quickly a wish like that can be taken away, and how little a father can do to stop it. I think about that birthday often now. It was the last happy day in that house, and none of us knew it, except perhaps my mother, who was watching from her doorway, as she always was, with those eyes of hers.
So Rosa was the one who was there. When Lucas scraped his knee, it was Rosa who cleaned it and kissed it better. When he had a nightmare, it was Rosa who sat on the edge of his bed until he fell asleep again. When he was hungry, it was Rosa who fed him, and when he was lonely, it was Rosa who listened. She did not do it for thanks. She did it because that was what she did, and because she loved him. I know that now. I knew it then, too, in some quiet corner of myself that I did not visit very often. I simply did not want to look at it too closely, because looking at it would have meant admitting that my wife was not raising our son, and that I was not raising him either, and that a woman we paid by the month was doing the work that belonged to us.
By the time Lucas was three, Rosa was not the help to him. She was the person who raised him. She raised me, he would say one day, in front of two hundred guests, and he would be telling the plain truth. I just did not know it yet.
My mother lived with us in those years, in the quiet rooms at the end of the upstairs hall. Catherine Harrington. She was old then, and frail, and her heart was weak, and the doctor had told her more than once to rest. She did not rest. She watched. That was what she did in her last years. She sat in her chair by the window, or she moved slowly through the house with her hand on the wall, and she watched everything.
She watched Victoria. That was the main thing she watched. She saw the dresses, and the shoes, and the luncheons, and the charity boards. She saw the credit card bills that arrived in thick envelopes, and she saw the way Victoria hid them at the bottom of the drawer. She saw the way Victoria spoke to Rosa, polite enough in front of other people, sharp as a knife when nobody was listening. She saw the way Victoria looked at Lucas, the way a woman looks at a duty she has already performed, and the way she looked at the necklace, the way a woman looks at a prize.
She tried to warn me. I remember her voice, thin and steady, in the evenings when Victoria was out and the house was quiet. That woman spends like the money will never run out, she said to me once. I laughed it off. I told her Victoria had her own money, and that a few dresses were nothing to worry about. Your boy needs his mother, Charles, she said another time, not a nanny and not a photograph. I told her she was old-fashioned, and that Victoria loved Lucas in her own way, and that I was too busy to argue about it. She did not argue. She simply looked at me with those eyes of hers, and I felt, for a moment, like a boy who had been caught in a lie, and then I went back to my business and forgot about it.